
On my way to teach, I sometimes pass the football team gathered in a darkened classroom, their faces illuminated by game footage flickering across a screen. I can’t help noticing their unwavering attention, their total absorption in the task at hand. Why can’t they be that engaged in my classes? I wonder resentfully.
And there it is again, my reflexive tendency to see athletics and academics as competing forces. I’m not proud of this zero-sum bias, which is why I work to challenge it. Lately, I’ve found a surprising ally in that effort: Netflix’s Last Chance U.
The documentary series follows junior college football players hoping to earn a spot at a four-year institution. Its five football seasons move from East Mississippi Community College (EMCC) to Independence Community College (ICC) in Kansas and finally to Laney College in Oakland, California. Funny, frustrating, and often heartbreaking, Last Chance U gives instructors a rare look into student-athletes’ lives—and how our assumptions can get in the way of teaching them well.
Acknowledge the intellectual work athletes already do
Professors aren’t always quick to recognize the intellectual demands of college athletics. The instructors featured in Last Chance U know better.
In the third season, English instructor LaTonya Pinkard reminds players at ICC that they have already memorized entire football playbooks. They learn formations, assignments, terminology, and contingencies, then recall all of it while 21 other players are moving around them. If they can master that kind of complicated system well enough to execute it under pressure, Pinkard suggests, they can master grammar too. The problem isn’t necessarily whether they can learn; sometimes it’s helping them recognize themselves as learners.
Linebacker Bobby Bruce makes that point especially well. His academic struggles could make it easy to underestimate him, but Pinkard refuses to do so. Bruce joins her book club, and in one classroom scene, he lights up when he answers a question correctly. It’s a small moment but an instructive one: Academic confidence can grow when someone gives a student reason to believe that success belongs to them too.
At Laney College, English instructor Judy Juanita also builds on knowledge her students already possess. When explaining plagiarism, she compares it to deliberately throwing a football game—using the rules, responsibilities, and sense of fair play they already understand on the field to make an academic principle concrete. Rather than treating football as something separate from learning, she makes it part of students’ education.
Athletes already know what it means to work at something difficult until it becomes second nature. That experience gives professors a strong foundation to build on.
Nurture relationships early
If there’s a breakout star in the first two seasons, it might be Brittany Wagner, the academic adviser at EMCC. Her office is a revolving door of players looking for pencils, help with assignments, or somewhere to hang out. They sprawl across her chairs and floor, interrupt her work, and test her patience. Wagner nags, cajoles, jokes, and refuses to let them disappear when things get difficult.
In one scene, she discovers that several players have a quiz in 30 minutes over Richard Connell’s “The Most Dangerous Game” and launches into an impromptu review session. In another, she pursues running back Dacorius “DJ” Law when he tries to escape a conversation about unfinished assignments.
Her patience isn’t limitless. In the second season, she’s visibly exasperated after players reveal a laissez-faire attitude toward cheating. Having invested so much time in their success, she’s understandably frustrated when they jeopardize their futures.
What makes Wagner effective isn’t simply her willingness to help students in trouble. It’s the relationships she’s established long before trouble arrives. Her office has become a gathering place, and casual conversations are as important as serious ones.
We needn’t turn our offices into student lounges to make ourselves approachable. A chat before class, a question about a weekend game, or a quick check-in after an absence can establish the trust that makes difficult conversations possible. Establishing relationships early gives us something to draw on if problems arise.
Don’t let one moment define a student
It’s easy to let one thing shape how we see a student: a frustrating moment, an outsized personality, a poor decision. Last Chance U is a good reminder of how incomplete those impressions can be.
Some players certainly test that instinct. In the first season, Law waits for an instructor who hasn’t arrived, announces that he’d leave if the cameras weren’t there, and promptly walks out when a crew member reminds him he’s free to do so. His unfinished assignments eventually catch up with him, and while his teammates graduate, Law must stay behind to complete his coursework. Watching scenes like this, I’m reminded how tempting it can be to let one behavior stand in for the whole student.
Ronald Ollie makes that temptation especially clear. The charismatic defensive lineman is a class clown who sometimes seems more interested in making people laugh than in paying attention. It would be easy to mistake that behavior for a lack of seriousness. But as the season unfolds, we learn more about the life behind it. Ollie was only five when his father killed his mother and then committed suicide, leaving him to grow up amid poverty and instability. His humor and bravado begin to look a little different once we know what sits behind them.
So does his progress. Ollie begins taking his schoolwork seriously, earns good grades, and graduates on time. The student who might initially look unserious turns out to be entirely capable of succeeding.
The lesson isn’t that every frustrating behavior has an explanation waiting to redeem it. It’s simply that a bad day, a bad decision, or even a pattern of poor choices still doesn’t tell us everything there is to know about a student.
Remember they are more than athletes
One of the series’s most affecting moments comes when linebacker Bobby Bruce breaks down crying over an injury. Pinkard reminds him, “Mr. Bruce, you’re more than football.” Her point extends well beyond that moment. For students whose schedules, friendships, ambitions, and even sense of self have long revolved around a sport, imagining an identity beyond it may not come easily.
At Laney College, offensive lineman Nu’u Taugavau offers another version of that lesson. He is pursuing football while supporting his wife and two young daughters. When a transfer opportunity arises, Coach John Beam questions whether relocating his entire family for another chance to play is realistic. Football matters deeply to Taugavau, but it’s only one part of a much larger life.
That distinction matters in our classrooms. “Student-athlete” may be the category through which we first know someone, but it should not become the boundary of what we expect from them. A literature course, chemistry lab, or history seminar may introduce an interest or ability a student has never had much reason to explore. Supporting those possibilities doesn’t require diminishing athletic goals. It simply means refusing to treat the athlete as the whole person.
Remember what you can’t see
There are the parts of students’ lives we may never glimpse at all. The Laney College season is particularly sobering in this respect. Many of these players are navigating hardships that most of my students can scarcely imagine. Oakland’s soaring housing costs leave some commuting up to two hours each way. Others sleep in cars or locker rooms. Many work demanding jobs while keeping up with football and classes.
Dior Walker-Scott works nights at a chicken restaurant and sleeps in his Ford Explorer, a secret he keeps from his mother. In one phone conversation, she asks whether he’s getting enough to eat. Sometimes, he admits, he isn’t. She won’t learn he’s homeless until the documentary airs.
In another season, running back Isaiah Wright struggles with injuries and increasingly tense relationships with his coaches. What they apparently don’t know is that his fiancée has suffered a miscarriage. Watching only his behavior, it would be easy to see a difficult young man. Knowing what is happening beyond those interactions makes that judgment much harder to sustain.
Professors necessarily draw conclusions from what happens in front of us. A student-athlete falls asleep, misses an assignment, or seems distracted, and we begin assembling explanations. Sometimes we’re right. Often, however, we have no idea what else that student is carrying. Last Chance U does not suggest that we lower our expectations. It does suggest that we leave a little room between what we observe and what we assume.
Nichole DeWall is a professor of English at McKendree University in Lebanon, Illinois, where she teaches Shakespeare, medieval and early modern literature, drama, and composition courses.
The post The Student-Athlete Reconsidered: Lessons from <i>Last Chance U</i> appeared first on The Teaching Professor.
