
At the start of each new semester, I look out at a room of nontraditional students and see the hidden superheroes of higher education. Returning to college after years of managing careers, family, and life’s many demands, they bring remarkable strength, resilience, and perspective to their studies. Their journey is as transformative as that of any Marvel or DC hero. They face unique trials, push through obstacles, and in the end emerge stronger and more capable.
As faculty, we can be their allies at every stage. Drawing on the arcs of these characters, let us look at how to help nontraditional students thrive by connecting them with their strengths and building an environment that brings out their best.
The call to adventure: Sparking Ms. Marvel’s determination
For nontraditional students, the decision to return to school is often fueled by a need for personal growth or career advancement or a long-held goal. Like Kamala Khan, better known as Ms. Marvel, who feels called to become more than she imagined possible, they sense they are capable of something bigger. Yet they may wonder whether they are ready, especially if it has been years since they were last in a classroom.
We can help students connect coursework to their goals through assignments that apply concepts to real situations. Early in the term, ask students to write a short goal-setting statement describing how they hope to use what they learn. This exercise helps them see the relevance of the material and builds personal commitment, creating a motivational anchor you can return to in later feedback.
Refusal of the call: Overcoming self-doubt, Daredevil style
Once they return, nontraditional students often encounter self-doubt. They may fear they’re “too old” or worry they won’t fit in. Daredevil offers a parallel. As Matt Murdock, he fears his blindness will keep him from being a hero, but as Daredevil he learns that it heightens his other senses, giving him exceptional perception and strength. Likewise, students come to see their life experiences, both successes and setbacks, as an asset that brings insight and resilience.
You can help students move past self-doubt by drawing on their strengths. In an early discussion forum or in-class activity, ask them to share past accomplishments, especially ones where they overcame challenges, and to name the qualities that helped them succeed. This reflective dialogue reassures them that those strengths transfer to their studies. When students connect new material to their own backgrounds, engagement deepens, and the class begins to explore varying perspectives formed by culture and lived experiences. Their pasts become the foundation for the class rather than a hidden collection of barriers.
Tests and allies: Balancing roles with Batgirl’s resilience
Once they’re back in school, nontraditional students encounter a series of tests. Juggling work, family, and academic deadlines is daunting. Like Batgirl, who balances her work as Barbara Gordon with her role as Gotham’s protector, they face the dual challenge of managing many roles while keeping their academic commitments.
One way to support students juggling work, family, and school is to offer flexible participation. If you grade participation, consider providing multiple ways to engage, such as synchronous discussions, recorded lectures, shared documents, or online boards, all of which accommodate different schedules. Encourage students to partner up as “accountability buddies” who trade reminders and support. Such peer bonds mirror the alliances superheroes rely on and build camaraderie that sustains students through hard stretches.
The inmost cave: Confronting Superman’s darkest moments
In every hero’s story, there’s a moment of crisis. For nontraditional students, it often comes when life’s responsibilities clash with school and leave them overwhelmed. Superman, who wrestles with his dual role as Clark Kent and the Man of Steel, knows this struggle, and it shows in moments of despair when he questions whether he can keep up with all the demands created by his dual roles.
At this stage, faculty can reach out with targeted support. If you notice a student struggling or missing work, send a personal email expressing concern and offering help. You might also hold “wellness checks” a few weeks before major deadlines, inviting students to name any outside challenges affecting their progress, perhaps through an LMS quiz or an office hour check-in. These moments help students feel supported and point them toward advising, tutoring, or counseling when they need it most.
The ordeal: Embracing final challenges with confidence
As nontraditional students near the end of their program, they face a final ordeal, often a capstone, final exam, or demanding paper. Like Black Widow confronting her complicated past, they must draw on everything they have learned and everything they have overcome to succeed.
To support them, organize “milestone” checkpoints within larger projects. If the final project is a major paper or capstone, break it into steps with mini deadlines, such as an outline, annotated bibliography, and rough draft, and give brief feedback at each stage. This practice eases the pressure of a single large deadline and lets you reinforce progress, giving students the confidence to finish strong.
The reward and return: Emerging as real-life heroes
After their final challenges, nontraditional students emerge with not just a degree but also renewed purpose and confidence. Like Ms. Marvel embracing her role or Superman recognizing the strength he brings to both of his identities, they leave transformed, having proven to themselves they can succeed and set an example for their families, peers, and communities.
Our role in their growth is more than instructional; it is transformative. By building a supportive environment, connecting coursework to real goals, honoring their experience, and celebrating their progress, we help nontraditional students move from the margins into full recognition. Though they wear no capes, their academic journey is nothing short of heroic, and we have the privilege of being part of their story. As they emerge with new skills and confidence, we are reminded that true heroes often walk among us, even in the quietest corners of our classrooms.
Kerri Augusto is a licensed psychologist and assistant professor in the bachelor of science in psychology and human services completion program at William James College.
The post Cape Not Required: Supporting the Heroic Journey of Nontraditional Students appeared first on The Teaching Professor.
