
Moving beyond standard instructional practices is a necessity in today’s diverse classrooms. Faculty are tasked with creating educational spaces that not only meet the varied learning needs of their students but also leverage their backgrounds. The good news? Effective models already exist.
This article outlines an integrated framework, known as Culturally Sustaining Universal Design for Learning (CSUDL), that marries Universal Design for Learning (UDL) with Culturally Sustaining Pedagogy (CSP). UDL provides the architectural blueprint for reducing barriers by offering multiple means of engagement, representation, and expression (CAST, 2024). CSP, conversely, provides the cultural nutrients, focusing on instruction that actively sustains linguistic and cultural pluralism (Paris & Alim, 2017). CSUDL represents a synergistic approach to education, one that meets all students equitably and affirmatively. It recognizes that true access to learning is not just about physical or cognitive accommodations; it’s also about ensuring that learning is relevant at the deepest level of culture.
The ultimate goal of postsecondary education is cultivating students as expert learners. Building that capacity for self-monitoring and advocacy has to start early. CSUDL focuses on making students partners in the learning process. This process of structured codesigning emphasizes the empowerment goals of CSP while tapping into UDL, resulting in personalized and authentic learning opportunities.
Here are specific actions you can take to implement CSUDL.
1. Codesign course structures.
Start with your syllabus and policies. Instead of presenting them as nonnegotiable mandates, collaborate with students to co-create them. Discuss which policies support learning for diverse learners and which might inadvertently create barriers. For example, rather than set an unyielding late-work rule, brainstorm an equitable policy that supports accountability while offering structured flexibility (e.g., three “oops tokens” per semester—tokens that students can submit in place of an assignment, no questions asked).
2. Introduce culture objectives.
Similar to learning objectives, culture objectives clearly articulate what students will be able to do to analyze how cultural perspectives, assumptions, and power structures shape knowledge and communication within a field. These objectives make explicit how students will examine whose perspectives are represented, whose are missing, and how social contexts influence the development, interpretation, and impact of disciplinary knowledge (Halualani & Nakayama, 2010; Medina, 2023). Unlike broad aims, culture objectives provide concrete targets that reflect students’ actual experiences within the classroom.
Review your content objectives, activities, readings, media, and assessments. Are diverse authors and perspectives (including, for example, racial, gender, geographic, and disciplinary diversity) represented? Go beyond a simple inclusion checklist; ensure that these voices are integral to the understanding of core concepts, not relegated to a single “diversity week.”
Example: In a course on organizational leadership, a culture objective might be: “Students will analyze how leadership styles are defined and practiced differently in two distinct cultural contexts (e.g., East Asian vs. Western European) and articulate how cultural values shape power dynamics.”
3. Decenter traditional authority.
In your planning documents (syllabi, assignment prompts), clearly state in course-level objectives that all students’ lived experiences and cultural knowledge are valuable assets to the class discussion. Example: “In this course, students’ lived experiences are not just anecdotes; they are valid forms of expertise that will enrich our analysis and challenge the traditional boundaries of the field. We are building knowledge together.”
Instructionally, go beyond theoretical assignments by using rich case studies drawn from diverse, complex professional scenarios. Alternatively, use experiential learning and get students out of the classroom, collaborating with community partners, or solving an actual problem. These forms of engagement allow students to interact with content differently, leading to deeper application and generalization. Frame your course not as a transfer of knowledge from expert (professor) to novice (student) but as a shared inquiry where diverse perspectives are essential for deep learning.
4. Build meaningful options into course activities.
Flexibility is the key to tapping into students’ lived experiences. Instead of providing unlimited or unclear choices, offer a small set of purposeful options that all support the same learning goal. This goes beyond just offering options for the final project.
You can build these options into several parts of a course:
- Materials: Present content through scholarly articles, textbook chapters, simulations, videos, and other formats.
- Tools: Provide collaborative platforms like shared documents and digital whiteboards rather than only individual work methods.
- Expression and submissions: Allow students to submit a podcast, visual presentation, or full essay (their choice) for a major assessment.
When students select resources and tools that resonate with their backgrounds or processing styles, the learning becomes inherently more authentic and meaningful.
5. Embed structured dialogue.
Structured dialogue is an instructional planning strategy that helps ensure CSUDL meaningfully shapes instruction. Students often deepen their understanding by explaining ideas to peers and hearing different perspectives, making intentional peer-to-peer exchange an important part of learning. Structured dialogue provides clear prompts, roles, and goals that guide these exchanges so they remain focused, productive, and inclusive. By contrast, when dialogue is left unstructured—without guidance or expectations—conversations can drift, participation may become uneven, and discussions about cultural differences may unintentionally reinforce stereotypes or existing biases (Bennett, 2017).
Use proven structures that promote participation and cross-cultural dialogue:
- Reciprocal teaching: Students take on roles (e.g., Questioner, Clarifier, Predictor, Summarizer) to help their group understand content. The reciprocal teaching strategy distributes the cognitive load and builds critical understanding by scaffolding how to process complex information.
- Inner circle/outer circle/Socratic seminar: This is a technique designed to maximize student dialogue, encourage participation from all students, and expose participants to a greater variety of perspectives than they might encounter in a more traditional discussion. Divide the class into two circles of partners. The inner circle remains stationary (facing outward), while the outer circle moves one person to the right after a timed interval, we generally do about five to seven minutes. This allows them a chance to discuss the prompt with a new partner at each new timed interval.
CSUDL offers a powerful path forward for college education. By blending the barrier-reducing principles of UDL with CSP’s focus on sustaining cultural pluralism, professors can enhance their instruction to foster authentic inclusion. This approach recognizes that achieving equitable access in education requires not only the reduction of cognitive, physical, and linguistic barriers but also the assurance that learning is culturally sustaining. Through practices like those we’ve outlined above, professors can deepen and extend learning for all students.
References
Bennett, M. J. (2017). Developmental model of intercultural sensitivity. In Y. Y. Kim (Ed.), The international encyclopedia of intercultural communication. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118783665.ieicc0182
CAST. (2024). Universal Design for Learning guidelines version 3.0. https://udlguidelines.cast.org
Halualani, R. T. & Nakayama, T. K. (2010). Critical intercultural communication studies: At a crossroads. In R. T. Halualani & T. K. Nakayama (Eds.), The handbook of critical intercultural communication (pp. 1–16). Blackwell.
Medina, J. (2023, March 22). Content, language, and culture learning targets. Language Magazine. https://languagemagazine.com/2023/03/22/content-language-and-culture-learning-targets
Paris, D., & Alim, H. S. (Eds.). (2017). Culturally sustaining pedagogies: Teaching and learning for justice in a changing world. Teachers College Press.
Amy Mercado is an assistant professor of Special Education at Bridgewater State University. Her work focuses on preparing future educators to design inclusive, neurodiversity-affirming classrooms through culturally sustaining pedagogy, Universal Design for Learning (UDL), and approaches that cultivate students’ learning power.
Alexandra Balconi is an associate professor of TESOL at Bridgewater State University, where she coordinates the TESOL certificate and minor programs. She integrates virtual exchange (COIL) into her teaching. Her research focuses on using COIL for intercultural competence in teacher preparation, social justice in teacher preparation, and language objectives development.
Kerri Olore, assistant professor of special education at BSU, leverages 20 years of K–12 experience to bridge theory and practice. Her research focuses on using culturally sustaining pedagogy and UDL to design equitable, dynamic learning environments. She is committed to guiding and mentoring future special educators toward student motivation and success.
Emily Spitzman, associate professor of TESOL at BSU, researches social justice in teacher preparation, critical intercultural communication, and linguistic awareness. Drawing from her experience teaching English to immigrants and refugees, she integrates culturally sustaining pedagogy and UDL, recently focusing on anti-racist and anti-bias approaches in international education.
The post Weaving UDL and Culturally Sustaining Pedagogy to Promote Inclusion appeared first on The Teaching Professor.
