How Teaching First-Years Has Made Me a Better Instructor

I have been teaching at the college and university level for the past 30 years, and for many of those years, I have taught introductory first-year courses. As I creep closer to retirement, I’ve been reflecting on how teaching first-years has challenged me over the years to improve my teaching skills and abilities. Below are five ways I believe teaching first-year courses have helped me be a better instructor.

1. Teaching first-years has helped me design ways to get students more involved and engaged in class.

Getting students to engage and participate in class is a challenge. I’ve had many conversations with colleagues over the years about teaching, and one theme that’s arisen repeatedly, probably more than any other, is how hard it is to get students to talk and participate in class. I’ve learned that it’s important to purposely build student engagement and participation into lectures on the front end to ensure that they’re happening when I teach.

Instructors often ask students questions in class and then get irritated when they sit there with blank stares on their faces and don’t respond. This can be especially true with first-years. One strategy I use to help students feel more comfortable speaking up in class is to have them get in groups of two or three and then write out the answer to a question I bring up in class. I tell students that each group will be required to share its answer with the rest of the class. This simple technique has made a big difference in students’ being more comfortable speaking and sharing in class.

Much has been written about techniques and strategies (like the one mentioned above) to get and keep students engaged in class and help them be more comfortable speaking in front of their peers. Two resources that have been particularly helpful to me over the years are Elizabeth Barkley’s Student Engagement Techniques: A Handbook for College Faculty and Ken Bain’s What the Best College Teachers Do.

2. Teaching first-years has helped me find a balance between flexibility and rigidity.

Students entering college have a wide range of high school experiences that shape their sense of academic expectations. Many first-years I talk to state that in high school, they were not penalized for turning in late work or, if they were, those penalties were minimal and rarely affected their grade. First-years quickly realize that the expectations of college instructors are usually different.

On a continuum of “very rigid” to “very flexible,” I lean more to the flexible end. I give students clear directions and expectations for graded assessments in class, but invariably, students will miss deadlines or turn in poor work. I follow the late work policies outlined in the syllabus, use grading rubrics for assignments, and so forth but also realize that things come up (e.g., car troubles, family emergencies, mental health struggles) that warrant flexibility and leniency.

When these situations arise, I take the time to communicate with the student and let them know how I am handling the situation and why (e.g., allowing them to turn in a late assignment or not) and what might happen if something similar happens in the future. For example, if a pattern arises where students are missing deadlines consistently, then I would afford them less leniency.

3. Teaching first-years has motivated me to help students develop better study strategies.

Many students enter college with poor study skills and habits. I believe this relates to the point that students are often not penalized for late or poor-quality work in high school. This invariably leads to first-years scoring poorly on an exam or assignment early in their first semester, which can be stressful and upsetting.

Over the years I’ve had many conversations with first-years regarding their high school academic experiences and whether they had much or any instruction about how to study effectively. Students usually report that they received little to no guidance in high school about effective ways to study.

I enjoy talking about study habits and strategies with my students as I find that most are genuinely interested in learning how to improve their study skills. Strategies like spreading out studying for an exam over weeks instead of days and using self-testing strategies instead of simply rereading notes or textbook chapters are ones students are often open to adopting. I also review and discuss our university’s resources on studying. Additionally, instructors can provide links to freely available studying resources in the syllabus or post them in the course learning management system and refer to them periodically so students know they are available.

[Editor’s note: On study habits, feel welcome to share the following Teaching Professor resources your students: “Study Strategies for Better Grades (and More Learning),” “A Memo to Students About Studying,” and “A Memo to Students About Studying for Finals.”]

4. Teaching first-years has helped me become more aware of student mental health challenges.

When I first started teaching, it was rare that students would reach out to me about the mental health challenges they were facing. I’m confident that many of the challenges students are experiencing today were also experienced by the students in the first classes I taught. Thankfully, things are different today. Students appear to be more open to asking for and receiving help, and institutions have more resources in place to provide mental health assistance to students.

I purposefully spend time in the classes I teach talking about mental health and encourage students to talk to me if they ever need to discuss something they are working through in their lives. I also spend time sharing with them the many resources that are available at our institution, including our Office of Student Life and the Counseling and Testing Center. I also share with them that on three or four occasions in my life I have sought out the help of a professional counselor and that each of those encounters has been extremely helpful.

Most institutions of higher education have mental health resources available to students, and I believe that it’s vital that instructors let students know what those resources are, how to contact them, and encourage students to use those resources should they ever feel they need to. Again, linking these resources in the syllabus or LMS and referring to them periodically may make it more likely that students will use them.

5. Teaching first-years has constantly reinforced the idea that my presence and enthusiasm are key.

While it may appear that students are uninterested and sometimes checked out while sitting in your class, the truth is that they are watching you. Your attitude and actions have a big impact on them and their motivation to want to be in class and, more importantly, engage with you and their classmates.

I teach a first-year seminar class that is a graduation requirement at my institution. Few students look forward to taking that class, and I believe the vast majority think it will be a complete waste of their time. But I love teaching the class as I’ve seen the positive effects on students from the many past sections of this class I have taught. Students pick up on my enthusiasm and excitement for the class, and some, at least, believe me when I tell them that they’ll learn new things in the course and that it will help them succeed in college.

Presence is something I talk with my students about frequently—the idea of “being there” or “being in the moment.” Presence is something we struggle with today, probably more than we did three decades ago. But students notice when your focus is on them, when you are really “there” with them in class, when you show flexibility when they need it, when you take 10 minutes to answer their questions after class without getting annoyed, when you show compassion for them, and when you genuinely care about them and their learning.


Brian Udermann is a professor in the Department of Exercise and Sport Science at the University of Wisconsin–La Crosse. He has over 30 years of collegiate teaching experience and has taught first-year students for the past 20 years.

The post How Teaching First-Years Has Made Me a Better Instructor appeared first on The Teaching Professor.