You are currently viewing Mutually Satisfied Mediocrity: When Indifferent Teachers Meet Indifferent Students

Mutually Satisfied Mediocrity: When Indifferent Teachers Meet Indifferent Students

There is an elusive win-win in teaching in which both teachers and students truly enjoy a class together. The teachers find pleasure and satisfaction in educating students, and the students are fully engaged in learning concepts they find interesting and meaningful. Unfortunately, some teachers and students never experience such moments. Faculty who see teaching as a chore probably doubt such moments could exist, so they never try to create them. Students who are focused more on passing a course than learning anything probably also doubt such an experience could happen in a class. Both teachers and students can approach a course with an embittered, cynical attitude. When they do, however, I argue that there can be another kind of win-win in which both teachers and students get what they want but neither benefits from the experience. Before I describe it though, I want to explore what jaded teachers and students each want out of a class.

Jaded teachers see teaching as a necessary obligation rather than a priority. Teaching is the price they have to pay for the opportunity to do what they really value, such as pursuing scholarship. Or they may be at an institution that neither prizes nor supports effective teaching. It may not count heavily toward tenure and promotion, and the acceptable norm for good teaching may be so low that mediocre teaching is sufficient. Such faculty may not even be aware of teaching methods that could make their teaching more effective, efficient, and enjoyable. For jaded faculty, “good” teaching practices are ones that require minimal effort to allow for more time for the truly important work of scholarship. Jaded teachers assume good students make for a good class. Good students come into their classes equipped with a deep interest in the topic and a strong background.[1] Such teachers believe that their sole responsibility is to present accurate information and explain it clearly. They expect students to grasp new concepts immediately and deeply. If they don’t understand it, that reflects on the student and not the teacher. Besides, student struggle is a good thing. Struggle that the teacher is rigorous, and once the student works through the struggle, the resulting learning will be stronger. Making information accessible and easy to grasp is dumbing down the material.

The goal of jaded students is to complete courses as quickly and with as little effort as possible, and they think teachers should understand and respect that goal. These students want teachers to tell them exactly what they need to do to get the grade they want and make sure it isn’t too difficult. Teachers shouldn’t waste time teaching stuff that will not be on the test or expect students to remember anything once the test is done. They should be understanding when students skip class in favor of other, more important priorities. At the same time, students should get credit for showing up for class and for at least putting forth some effort. The best assignments are ones students can complete with minimal effort and learning. There should always be opportunities to make up for bad grades.

When indifferent teachers meet indifferent students, there is a way that both can satisfy the other—a kind of win-win that I call mutually satisfied mediocrity (MSM). Here’s how it works. The teacher tells the students exactly what they need to know or do to get the grade they want. For example, they can provide a study guide for exams with the specific information that students need to give back as answers on the exam to do well. Students have to reproduce information but don’t have to understand it. Faculty may also set assignments that require effort to complete but not learning. Getting a good grade requires only memorizing the study guide or following instructions on assignments. The teacher has fulfilled their obligations and can now focus on research. The students have earned their desired grades and progressed toward their degrees. The teacher gets positive course evaluations for promotion and tenure. Teachers and students make lives easier for each other. Neither has to ever think about the class again.

I worry that MSM is more common than we’d like to think and far more common than the win-win of teachers and students excited about learning. MSM is the easier path for both teachers and students. Great teaching, however, is a selfless act, prioritizing student learning above one’s own ego and convenience. And although we tend to think that students come into our classes with a certain level of motivation, I believe that great teachers can create great students. Great students, in turn, can inspire teachers. Let’s avoid the trap of MSM and strive for the win-win that benefits both teachers and students.

[1]. Ideally, students already know what the teacher is supposed to teach them. It makes teaching easy and look effective.


Stephen L. Chew is a professor of psychology at Samford University. Trained as a cognitive psychologist, he endeavors to translate cognitive research into forms that are useful for teachers and students. He is the recipient of multiple awards for his teaching and research. Author contact: slchew@samford.edu.

The post Mutually Satisfied Mediocrity: When Indifferent Teachers Meet Indifferent Students appeared first on The Teaching Professor.