You are currently viewing Back to School: Baby Boomers Weigh In on Their Gen Z Classmates

Back to School: Baby Boomers Weigh In on Their Gen Z Classmates

It’s an age-old question of seasoned educators: Is it me who’s changed, or is it my students?

An honest answer is fraught with problems. It’s not just a pedagogical inquiry but a hard look into one’s own aging and all the baggage that comes with it. Not only that: It can be difficult to recognize gradual changes in oneself as well as shifting externalities. It’s like the frog that fails to notice the slowly heating water or the fish that doesn’t register the very water it’s swimming in—choose the aquatic analogy you prefer. Perhaps Gen Z really is less willing to read, is more reticent to speak up in class, and expects high grades for minimal efforts. Or maybe the “curse of expertise” (Schorschinsky, 2019) has led me to draw faulty conclusions about my own students.

In an attempt to grapple with this educational conundrum, I turned to a cohort that might shed some welcome light: baby boomer auditors who, after long careers, returned to classrooms decades later to sit shoulder to shoulder with Gen Z students. Could they detect differences that I just can’t see?

I decided to find out by running a focus group with five boomers (three men, two women) who’ve gone back to school in retirement. One was new to my school’s FILL program (see Burkholder & Peabody, 2021) last semester, while the rest have taken a variety of courses with me and other faculty. Their biographies reveal a range of undergraduate and graduate degrees, from institutions both public and private, open and exclusive. All of them appeared to enjoy successful careers at prestigious firms in such areas as finance, fashion, accounting, pharmaceuticals, and business. Although I can’t know for certain, I suspect they were all diligent undergrads who genuinely enjoyed learning, so much so that they opted to return to college later in life.

As a framework for thinking about Gen Z students before our meeting on Zoom, I tasked them with reading three essays in the Understanding the Gen Z Student collection (2025) put out by The Chronicle of Higher Education. One essay was critical of Gen Z, another sympathetic, and a third more neutral. I prepared some questions for the group in advance, but I gave great latitude for participants to go where the conversation took them.

So what were their impressions of Gen Z students? And, as a Gen Xer who’s been teaching for nearly 30 years, am I seeing what the boomers see? Is nostalgia bias causing me to remember things that were never there? Is recency bias having an undue effect?

Study habits and reading challenges

Focus group participants saw Gen Z as less prepared, less likely to complete readings, and less engaged in class discussions than their own generation was. Michael (all names are pseudonyms) felt his college peers were more accountable for their own learning. “We had more responsibility,” he said. “You [were] more responsible for ensuring that you attended the classes, you understood the work that had to be done, you studied for the exams.” Jim highlighted Gen Z’s passivity in class, saying that “students are not as interactive and are not questioning as much” as when he was an undergrad. Pam concurred, though she felt that “it depends on the personality of the professors,” both then and now.

Current students’ lack of preparation for class meetings stood out to Andy. “It seems as though many of the students haven’t really done the reading to be prepared for the class,” he said, noting that “there might be a handful” of people showing evidence of having taken homework seriously. “Kids just don’t want to do it,” Pam chimed in about Gen Z’s reading habits, with Angela remembering a recent news story highlighting the dearth of reading in high school, leaving today’s college students ill-equipped. Michael likewise pointed out “the decline in reading skills.” Asked whether their observations reinforced one of the articles in the Chronicle collection on this topic, Andy said it “seemed to describe what I’ve experienced in my tenure here.”

Unsurprisingly, participants called out technology and social media as culprits. Jim suggested that the inherently short posts of social media have a deleterious effect on extended concentration abilities. Michael and Andy both brought up laptops and smartphones as educational nuisances, though they also commended my protocol for reducing phone distractions in class (Burkholder, 2017). At the same time, Michael observed that there have always been technologies vying for attention, including television and radio. Jim pushed back even more on the putative novelty of distractions. “When I went to college, the drinking age was 18,” he recalled. “The ease of getting drunk, and booze, and heavy drinking in college” was magnified, with the campus pub being “a mob scene” on certain nights of the week.

Changes in classroom authority

All participants agreed that college was more formal when they were undergrads. Professors and students were better attired, and that formality translated to greater deference paid to instructors. Angela put the matter bluntly, admitting she had been “terrified” of her professors. Pam agreed: “The professor ruled the classroom . . . and there wasn’t any kind of nonsense.” Deference to a professor’s expertise seemed to manifest in teaching styles, which relied more heavily on lecturing. Andy and Jim attended very different institutions—one a large public, the other a small private—but they both recalled a preponderance of lecturing as opposed to group work. Andy saw an upside to instructor-centered teaching, saying that regular attendance and diligent note-taking during lectures were important for understanding material that might appear on tests.

Discussion then turned to spontaneous remarks on the effects of students’ evaluating their professors. Only one of the boomers could remember doing so as an undergrad, but Pam felt the now-common practice “puts some pressure on how professors conduct their classes.” Leniency toward poor work is an inevitable result, a point Jim makes below, but institutional policies have exacerbated the problem of an overly permissive environment. Pam referenced recent syllabi indicating that students could drop courses as late as the last week of classes, whereas undergrads of her generation had to decide within a couple weeks whether to withdraw. She was stunned when I informed her that students could now drop even after classes finished (but before finals), and that this was a recent development (withdrawal deadlines used to be weeks earlier). “Oh, jeez,” she reacted. “So you can kind of say, ‘I don’t like my grade, I’m going to drop the course now.’ I mean, that’s kind of silly.”

Hand-holding and transactional attitudes

The focus group was disheartened by the amount of remedial training in today’s classrooms. Angela drew attention to an assessment on proper Chicago-style footnoting in my own upper-division historical methods course. Knowledge of this skill was essential, she admitted; nevertheless, she was “really taken aback when you needed to spend time as a college professor” on such a skill since she had “learned that in high school” and had it “down cold when I went to college.” Michael similarly remarked on what he perceived as more students needing remedial training, even full courses, for skills that “they should have been prepared for in high school.”

I pressed the group a bit by asking whether they saw Gen Z as more transactional toward their college experience, viewing themselves more as customers than learners. Pam acknowledged this reality as well as the downside: Due to demographic changes, it’s a buyer’s market, where “colleges have to attract students as consumers.” Andy likewise put things into cold economic terms, observing that “the supply of colleges is higher than the demand, and so that changes the dynamic quite a bit.” The implications were obvious to Jim: “Universities and colleges have had to, whether it’s reluctant or not, lower their standards.”

Unready for the realities of the workplace

The focus group was united in thinking there’s been a diminution in work ethic since they attended college. Angela and Pam both described this decline through their long records of mentoring college interns and new grads. “You were really fortunate if you got somebody who showed up on time every day,” noted Angela, adding that “most of them just hadn’t even developed that basic skill.” Pam sympathized, saying that she found “the transition of coming from college and going into a business environment more difficult for them.” Yet both of them admitted this was an issue predating Gen Z. Jim agreed, estimating that the decay in work ethic went back at least 20 years. Andy was of the opinion that higher college course failure rates might make a dent in these deficiencies, though he couldn’t speak to actual failure statistics. He placed further blame on helicopter parents who enable their children’s bad habits. Pam and Jim suggested that tackling poor attitudes toward college and professional work was much needed but would require broader societal action, including reforms at the K–12 levels.

Angela then pointed to younger students’ inability to think outside the box, citing what she called “a lack of curiosity” among many learners in a major capstone course she had taken. These senior students, she explained, showed minimal effort and creativity when it came to their final project presentations. “They were taking what they had already learned, and they weren’t really going much deeper,” she said, though she admitted that a select few did opt to go more off the beaten path.

Comfortable in their own skin?

I ran a poll of all my Gen Z students this past semester asking them whether they wish they’d been born at different times (they could respond affirmatively to as many options as they wanted). Just about all of them (95 percent) reported being happy with their current age. Still, nearly a quarter were tempted to be members of Gen X (born 1965–80), with another quarter showing interest in being a millennial (1981–96), even though either choice would make them older today. Very few (just 15 percent) were intrigued by a later birth date in 2030 or 2050, suggesting a certain pessimism toward the future.

What about my baby boomers? You might think they all desired to be young again and thus opted for a later birth year, but that was not the case. None of them would choose to be 20 years old today, nor would they want to be born at some point in the future. They were all perfectly happy with their current age. Why?

“Sure, I’d love to be 20 years old,” Andy admitted. But, he added, “I enjoyed my school experience, and I’ve enjoyed my life since then, so I don’t really want to start over.” Angela had a more concrete reason not to covet youth. “When I look at what the job market looks like for them, and what AI may or may not be able to do, it’s pretty scary,” she said. Jim added that “technology, you know, the phones, the laptops,” though beneficial in ways, have “taken a lot of fun out of being a kid,” whether at the K–12 or college level. Michael expressed regret that, unlike when he was an undergrad, college is now effectively vocational training, where majoring in one of the humanities, as he had, “becomes a luxury.”

What I learned

Much of what the boomers said resonated with me, though it’s hard to know whether I’m just nostalgic for a college world that never really existed. And there was some pessimism about issues that are perhaps explained by the changing demographics of college populations, fluctuating cultural norms, and shifts in our understandings of teaching and learning, among other factors. Like my focus group, I was probably more driven as an undergrad than most of my students are. Still, kids will be kids. “College was fun,” said Pam, and “I look back in horror at some of the things that I did.” That’s something I can fully agree with. And if I play my cards right, I may someday be part of a retired Gen X focus group asked to weigh in on Generation Alpha. I’ll be ready for it.


Pete Burkholder is professor of history at Fairleigh Dickinson University, where he served as founding chair of the faculty teaching development program from 2009 to 2017. He is on the editorial board of The Teaching Professor and the national advisory board of the Society for History Education.

The post Back to School: Baby Boomers Weigh In on Their Gen Z Classmates appeared first on The Teaching Professor.