
I sidestepped the question for years.
“Should we address you as Professor, Doctor, Nichole, or . . . ?” a student would ask. “Oh, whatever you want,” I’d reply breezily. “I’m not fussy.”
Students’ names, of course, have always been sacrosanct. But insisting on a specific title for myself? How vain. I wasn’t one of those professors.
I now state my preferred form of address, Professor DeWall, within the first minutes of class on day one. Here’s what shifted for me.
A call for clarity
For students—particularly those new to college or unfamiliar with academic norms—“call me whatever” may not feel flexible. It may feel like a test with no grading rubric.
When we decline to clarify how we wish to be addressed, we quietly transfer that cognitive labor to our students: What if I get it wrong? Will this title sound respectful or stiff? What’s safest? This is the hidden curriculum at work, the unspoken rules students are expected to intuit on their own.
Some students are better equipped to navigate that ambiguity. Others are newer to these norms: a first-year who has never addressed someone with a doctoral title, a transfer student adjusting to a new institutional culture, an international student translating honorifics in real time, a first-generation student whose prior teachers were always “Mr.” or “Ms.,” or a student from a military background for whom “ma’am” or “sir” feels almost automatic. Each is scanning for cues about how to belong.
When we leave our preferences unspoken, students watch. They mimic. They triangulate from how others address us.
That vigilance is costly. I saw as much while observing a colleague’s class several semesters ago. In the middle of discussion, a student began, “Um . . . Professor—sorry, Dr. . . . I mean—” A handful of classmates laughed softly. My colleague smiled and waved it away: “Whatever is fine.”
The moment seemed harmless. But the shift was immediate. The student’s shoulders drew in; her comment lost its footing. When she resumed, she spoke faster and more cautiously.
Multiply that experience across a semester, across dozens of exchanges with students already unsure whether they belong. Over time, students begin to perform a quiet calculus that shapes participation: who speaks early, who hesitates, and who remains silent when uncertainty feels too risky.
I’ve also witnessed how clarity lowers the stakes of entry. “Hi, um . . .” my student uttered one afternoon, stepping hesitantly across the threshold of my office. A lingering pause. Then he glimpsed the name placard hanging on my door and audibly exhaled. “Dr. DeWall,” he said, suddenly steadier. “I was hoping you could read this draft of my Hamlet essay.”
It wasn’t office-hours jitters that had stalled him; he simply didn’t know how to address me. And once he did, we could turn our attention to the work.
A teachable moment
Failing to state form-of-address preferences squanders a small but important opportunity to set the tone from the first day.
A title alone does not determine classroom climate. I’ve known plenty of “Call me by my first name” professors who felt chilly and remote and plenty of “Doctor” or “Professor” instructors who were deeply generous. Titles aren’t everything.
But they’re not nothing either. The first day of class is filled with small, declarative moments. “Here’s how we’ll structure discussion.” “Here’s how we’ll submit work.” “Here’s how we’ll give feedback.” Each carries pedagogical intent.
The same is true for stating a preferred form of address. When we make that choice explicit and connect it to the aims of the course, we shift it from personality to purpose:
- “I go by Dr. DeWall. Using my title helps establish clear roles, which makes the classroom feel predictable and fair, especially when we’re navigating evaluation and feedback.”
- “Dr. DeWall works for me. The title signals that this course is anchored in a larger scholarly conversation. We’re not just trading opinions; we’re working within a discipline.”
- “I’m Nichole in this space. I choose first names to signal that we’re coinvestigators in the material. I design the course, but the thinking is something we build together.”
- “Nichole works. I’m aiming for a classroom where ideas can be tested openly and rigorously without unnecessary formality getting in the way.”
- “Please call me Professor DeWall. It’s a professional form of address that applies broadly, regardless of degree, and using the title ‘Professor’ creates consistency across the different instructors you’ll encounter.”
Notice how each of these makes the “why” visible.
A student once wrote in a midterm evaluation, “I like that you explain why we’re doing stuff. The classroom doesn’t have, like, a super random vibe.”
That phrasing made me smile, but it also made a point. Students are highly attuned to whether classroom norms feel intentional or arbitrary. Forms of address are part of that design.
A shared obligation
Being explicit about forms of address should be understood as a collective faculty responsibility. Without broad buy-in, the reputational cost of stating a title is not evenly distributed.
Imagine, for example, that a white male professor and his Black female colleague are team-teaching a course. During first-day introductions, he makes no mention of how he prefers to be addressed. A few minutes later, she says, “I prefer to be addressed as Dr. Williams.”
Neither choice is inherently weighty. But a substantial body of research shows that women faculty—especially female faculty of color—are more likely to be described as unapproachable for behaviors that are read as neutral or authoritative in their male colleagues. For her, the first-day introduction may carry extra weight: Will specifying my form of address be read as clarity or rigidity? Confidence or coldness? Will I spend the rest of the semester managing an impression formed in the first 30 seconds? Will it echo in student evaluations? If only one instructor is doing that mental math, the practice itself is uneven.
A gay male colleague once told me that early in his career, he hesitated to announce his preferred form of address. It wasn’t the title itself that concerned him; it was the potential reading. Would clearly stating a formal preference be filtered through familiar stereotypes (sassy, theatrical, overly attention seeking, performative)? Rather than risk confirming that caricature, he chose the option least likely to be misread: not naming a preference at all.
What’s true of student evaluations is true here as well: By naming patterns collectively, we diminish their force. When instructors—especially those in relative positions of privilege—briefly clarify how they wish to be addressed, the act ceases to signal ego or insecurity. It becomes predictable. Unremarkable.
Less risky because it’s routine.
Nichole DeWall is a professor of English at McKendree University in Lebanon, Illinois, where she teaches Shakespeare, medieval and early modern literature, drama, and composition courses.
The post The Cost of “Call Me Whatever” appeared first on The Teaching Professor.
