
In my third year as a full-time professor of education, I can’t exactly say I’m stuck. But I’d be less than honest if I didn’t admit that I sometimes wonder whether my instructional habits have started defaulting to what’s comfortable rather than what’s most effective. That feeling is the nudge that pushed me to try something this year that I hadn’t done since my days as a K–8 teacher and instructional coach, which was to pull up a chair in the back of a colleague’s classroom and simply observe.
What I discovered is that watching someone else’s classroom is also a way of peering into your own. You see what you’re doing, what you’ve stopped doing, and what you’ve never tried, in ways that a workshop or a self-reflection prompt rarely surfaces.
In my K–8 roles, observing other teachers was just part of the culture. You did it regularly, you talked about it openly, and you left with things you could use the very next day. When I transitioned into higher ed, I was surprised that it was a less common practice. Peer observation still happens in some institutions, but typically as a requirement tied to tenure review or annual evaluation. That’s precisely the problem (Akhmedova & Rozikova, 2021). Faculty who experience observation as an administrative box to tick view it with annoyance and even anxiety. But those who seek it out voluntarily, for their own growth, commonly describe it as one of the most valuable professional development experiences they’ve had.
Recently, I sat in on a couple of classes in departments outside my own: one in sports and exercise management and one in marketing. Research suggests that cross-disciplinary observation is particularly rich, and I have found that to be true. When you’re not tracking the content, you start noticing everything else (Cassada et al., 2017). You see what the instructor does in the first three minutes and the last three. You watch how they respond when a student gives a wrong answer. You notice whether the room feels like a place students want to be.
That last one is hard to get out of a workshop. But it’s what has had the biggest impact on my own teaching, and it’s something you can only see by actually being there.
My marketing colleague did something in the opening minutes of class that I’ve been thinking about ever since. He had music playing as students walked in. He stood at the door, greeted each student by name (a practice commonly referred to as “threshold”), and at the start of class joked that he realized that he was, in fact, “the only thing standing between them and the beautiful weather outside.” Later, he personally said goodbye to every student on the way out, encouraging those who had games or performances over the weekend.
None of this was just for show. Each move told students they were seen and in a safe place to learn. That vibe carried throughout the lesson, as he responded to student questions with enthusiastic, genuine affirmation (“I love that question, fantastic!”), drawing on the lived experience of students who had actually worked at the restaurant he used as a case study, and creating small-group structures where students could think through problems together before bringing them back to whole-class discussion.
My colleague in sports and exercise management did something similar but put her own spin on things. She is warm and naturally relational, and what struck me was how that relational ease raised the academic bar. Students were willing to brainstorm out loud and push their thinking further because she had created a space where their ideas were taken seriously. When she asked follow-up questions about students’ brainstorming, pushing for not only what they were thinking but also why and what else, students stepped up rather than shut down.
Many of us in higher education treat relationship building and academic rigor as separate concerns, maybe even at odds with one another. What I witnessed in these two classrooms directly challenged that assumption. What observers consistently report taking back after watching skilled colleagues is not content knowledge. It’s these relational and environmental moves that unlock student engagement (Hendry & Oliver, 2012; Bell, 2001).
What you can do: Pick one threshold move, whether that’s greeting students at the door, learning two or three new names per week, or ending class by personally acknowledging students as they leave, and commit to it for a month. Watch what happens to who shows up, who participates, and how. You don’t need to overhaul your personality. You just need one deliberate signal that says “you matter here.”
Both colleagues also did something I found myself furiously scribbling notes about. They were extraordinarily intentional about how they opened and closed every class period. My marketing colleague stated his learning objective at the start of class and returned to it verbatim at the end with “Did I do my job?,” inviting students to actually evaluate whether the lesson had delivered on its promise. My sports and exercise management colleague opened by looping back to where the class had left off the previous week (“We left off with . . .”), orienting students before introducing anything new.
Retrieving prior learning before introducing new material is one of the most reliably effective cognitive strategies we have, and bringing closure to a lesson by asking students to assess whether it met the objective develops the metacognitive awareness we want students to practice in all of their courses. Atkinson and Bolt (2010) found that faculty consistently take back from peer observation these structural practices, specifically ways of framing, connecting, and closing that they hadn’t incorporated in their own teaching before.
It’s easy to minimize these practices, but they are precisely the kinds of support that students need. Clear logistics, objectives, and previews of what’s next all reduce cognitive load and let students spend their mental energy on learning rather than on wondering what’s going on. You often can’t see that from where you’re standing. Sometimes you need to peer in from somewhere else first.
What you can do: Before your next class, write out your learning objective as a simple sentence starting with “By the end of today, students will be able to . . .” Say it out loud at the beginning. Return to it at the end. Ask students, genuinely, whether you got there. Then try opening the next class by spending three minutes on what you covered last time, not by restating it yourself, but by asking students to reconstruct it. Notice what they remember and what they’ve lost. That’s formative feedback you can use.
No matter how many years you’ve taught, or how many conferences you’ve attended on active learning and student engagement, I’d encourage you to try the simplest version of professional development there is. Find a colleague you’ve heard good things about, tell them why you’re curious about their teaching, and ask whether you can sit quietly in the back of their room for a class period for no reason other than to observe.
What peer observation gives you that no workshop can is the irreplaceable experience of seeing good teaching happen in real time, with real students, in real conditions, including the moments when the technology fails, and your colleague keeps going anyway. Bell (2001) found that more than 75 percent of faculty who participated in peer observation, even in formal programs, adjusted their teaching practices immediately after the visit.
I believe it. I did too.
We often say we want to be lifelong learners, not just in our disciplines but in how we teach them. Peer observation is one of the best ways to live that out. If you’ve been feeling even a little stuck, it’s worth trying. Your next breakthrough could be happening in a classroom two buildings over or maybe just down the hall.
References
Akhmedova, F., & Rozikova, R. (2021). The university teachers’ perceptions of peer observation. Eurasian Union of Scientists, 6(87), 4–9. https://doi.org/10.31618/ESU.2413-9335.2021.1.87.1396
Atkinson, D., & Bolt, S. (2010). Using teaching observations to reflect upon and improve teaching practice in higher education. Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning, 10(3), 1–19. https://scholarworks.iu.edu/journals/index.php/josotl/article/view/1798
Bell, M. (2001). Supported reflective practice: A programme of peer observation and feedback for academic teaching development. The International Journal for Academic Development, 6(1), 29–39. https://doi.org/10.1080/13601440110033643
Cassada, K. M., Harris, J., Herling, B., Warren, T., & Brown-Kidd, D. (2017). Engaging the power of peer observation. VASCD Journal, 14, 71–83. https://scholarship.richmond.edu/spcs-faculty-publications/77
Hendry, G. D., & Oliver, G. R. (2012). Seeing is believing: The benefits of peer observation. Journal of University Teaching & Learning Practice, 9(1), Article 7. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ974926.pdf
Kristine Wegner is an assistant professor in the School of Education at Wisconsin Lutheran College. She is passionate about faculty development in pedagogical practices and is currently a doctoral candidate at Concordia University Wisconsin, researching peer observation of teaching in higher education. In addition to her teaching load, she enjoys mentoring and supervising student teachers and clinical and practicum students.
The post Feeling Stuck? Observe One of Your Peers appeared first on The Teaching Professor.
