You are currently viewing Why Grade Limits Won’t Solve Grade Inflation

Why Grade Limits Won’t Solve Grade Inflation

As I write, the faculty at Harvard have just voted to limit the number of A grades they award in any undergraduate course to a maximum of 20 percent of class enrollment in an effort to combat grade inflation (McMurtrie, 2026). This policy is an arbitrary solution to a real problem. My father liked to tell a story about his first year in the chemical engineering program at the University of Texas. He registered for a physics class intended for high-achieving students. On the first exam, the lowest score was 93 out of 100. Would it make any sense to award As only to the top 20 percent? Clearly not; everyone did well and showed mastery of the material. Differences in scores probably reflected random differences in conscientiousness, silly mistakes, and who wasn’t feeling their best that day. The purpose of setting a limit on the number of A grades is to differentiate among students, but that assumes reliability and validity in grading. For reliability, the same students should score consistently in the top 20 percent on each exam. Validity means that the differences in grades reflect real differences in learning and understanding. The grade limit becomes meaningless if random nonacademic factors dictate who scores at the top and there aren’t meaningful differences in mastery among grades.

Courses in any major vary in intellectual rigor. Some emphasize foundational concepts that are within most any student’s grasp yet critical to master. Other courses are highly demanding, requiring mastery of complex concepts predicated on a firm understanding of foundational concepts. Both courses are integral to the major. It makes no sense to impose the same grade structure on both kinds of classes. The purpose of the first course is to develop foundational knowledge to prepare students for advanced study. This level is within the reach of most students who make sufficient effort. The second course differentiates students along the lines of effort and ability. Grade differences should be more meaningful in these kinds of courses. Furthermore, any instructor knows that the number of high-achieving students varies from class to class, and sometimes it will exceed 20 percent, especially at selective institutions. A uniform grade limit punishes more talented classes.

The new grade policy was initiated in response to a report on grade inflation at Harvard College (Claybaugh, 2025). The report notes that students come to college with a wide range of existing knowledge and skills. Calculus is a prime example. Almost half of school districts in the US do not offer calculus in any of their high schools (Cattell & Frankenberg, 2023), and many more districts can offer calculus at only some of their high schools and inconsistently from year to year. In 2019, about 16 percent of high school seniors had taken a calculus course (Bressoud, 2022), with the clear majority of those students in socioeconomically privileged areas. Introductory calculus is required for STEM and other quantitatively oriented majors. Students who have already taken a high-quality calculus class in high school have a clear advantage over those who are learning the concepts for the first time. The 20 percent rule in introductory calculus may end up reflecting which students took calculus in high school rather than math ability and motivation, and it may discourage or prevent motivated students from pursuing their desired majors (Butcher et al., 2014).

When students know that only the top 20 percent can earn As, they will focus more on grades than learning. A major challenge in teaching is to get students to focus more on learning and personal development than on grades, to take intellectual risks and reach for goals beyond their comfort zone. Grade limits make that challenge even more difficult (Liu et al., 2024). A recent study found that perfectionism in college students is at its highest level ever (American Psychological Association, 2026). Instead of seeking out professors who will challenge them, students will seek out professors who are reputed to be easier graders. The temptation to cheat using AI, already a threat, will get even stronger as students compete for that top 20 percent.

If there are so many reasons why grade limits are not a good solution to grade inflation, then why would faculty support it? I can think of two reasons. First, grade limits are easy to implement. They take no extra effort on the part of faculty, and they do not increase the time and effort spent teaching. Second, grade limits reduce the instructor’s personal responsibility for assigning student grades. When students complain that they did not get the grade they wanted, instructors can point to the policy as a reason why the students got the grade they did. For faculty who do not prioritize effective teaching and student learning, both these reasons are appealing.

If limits are not the answer to grade inflation, then what is? Let’s start by defining grade inflation. I define it as a comprehensive upward shift in course grades over time without a corresponding increase in actual learning. From this definition, then, the answer is to ensure that grades truly reflect student learning, which is challenging and difficult to do. Faculty who teach separate sections of a given course (let’s stick with introductory calculus) will need to discuss what students should know and be able to do after taking the course that they could not do before. There needs to be some flexibility built into course goals to account for differences among the faculty teaching the course, but there also has to be sound foundational agreement about what the students should be learning and what the students should be able to do. Then each faculty member has to operationalize those goals into assessments that measure student achievement. Every faculty member should be able to show the evidence that their students have or have not achieved those goals. That, of course, is a lot of work. In my field of psychology, the American Psychological Association has developed guidelines (American Psychological Association, 2023) for the undergraduate psychology major to help guide assessment of student skills and knowledge. The document (known to psychology teachers as Guidelines 3.0 because it is in its third edition) is in wide use across undergraduate psychology departments to guide assessment and development of the psychology major. Furthermore, the APA created a task force to provide guidance for teachers of introductory psychology (Gurung & Neufeld, 2021). The task force established common student learning outcomes and described ways of assessing each one. Both documents help guide the development of meaningful assessments of student learning. I’m sure professional organizations in other disciplines have also developed common outcomes for popular courses. Faculty can develop and justify grading schemes based on those goals and assessments. And what if the vast majority of the class makes an A? If a faculty member can show that the grade truly reflects student learning, then that isn’t grade inflation.

References

American Psychological Association.(2023). APA guidelines for the undergraduate psychology major: Version 3.0. American Psychological Association. https://www.apa.org/about/policy/undergraduate-psychology-major.pdf

American Psychological Association. (2026, May 28). Young adults are more perfectionistic than ever before. https://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/2026/05/young-adults-perfectionistic

Bressoud, D. (2022, September 1). The decline in high school calculus. MAA Communications. https://www.maa.org/news/the-decline-in-high-school-calculus

Butcher, K. F., McEwan, P. J., & Weerapana, A. (2014). The effects of an anti-grade-inflation policy at Wellesley College. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 28(3), 189–204. https://doi.org/10.1257/jep.28.3.189

Cattell, M., Jr., & Frankenberg, E. (2023, December 12). Who takes calculus courses? An analysis of CRDC data from 2011–2021. Calculus, Opportunity, and Equity. https://calculusopportunityequity.org/who-takes-calculus-courses

Claybaugh, A. (2025, October). Re-centering academics at Harvard College: Update on grading and workload. Office of Undergraduate Education, Harvard University. https://ouedocumentlibrary.fas.harvard.edu/sites/g/files/omnuum1616/files/2025-10/Update_on_Grading_October.27.2025.pdf

Gurung, R. A. R., & Neufeld, G. (Eds.). (2021). Transforming introductory psychology: Expert advice on teacher training, course design, and student success. American Psychological Association.

Liu, J., Wong, M., & Hard, B. (2024). The impact of norm‑ and criterion‑referenced grading systems on students’ course‑related expectations. Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning, 24(4), 43–60. https://doi.org/10.14434/josotl.v24i4.35434

McMurtrie, B. (2026, May 20). Harvard College faculty votes to limit A’s. The Chronicle of Higher Education. https://www.chronicle.com/article/harvard-college-faculty-votes-to-limit-as


Stephen L. Chew is a cognitive psychologist who endeavors to translate cognitive research into forms that are useful for teachers and students. He is the recipient of multiple awards for his teaching and research. He was a long serving professor of psychology, now retired. Author contact: slchew@samford.edu.

The post Why Grade Limits Won’t Solve Grade Inflation appeared first on The Teaching Professor.