
Moot court is a useful activity for students, especially those considering going to law school or pursuing careers in the legal profession. Given that law school applicants do not come from one discipline, moot court applies to a variety of academic programs. Strong existing intercollegiate competitions exist from Harvard to Iowa to Liberty University. But attendance at such events can be cost-prohibitive. This article will help professors incorporate such an in-class debate in their classes.
Moot court differs from mock trial in that such contests are not about “trying a case,” before a jury or at a bench trial, though judges play a role. “Moot court requires participants to apply the law to the facts of a fictional case, arguing for either the respondent who won in the lower court, or for the challenging petitioner,” writes Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute. “Facts of moot court cases are written so that they are balanced and do not overwhelmingly favor one participant’s argument over the other.”
The competition tests the participants’ oral and written skills. “During moot court, participants first receive an appellate record of the fictional case and then typically write an appellate brief,” the Legal Information Institute writes.
They may be allowed to select the side of the case they wish to represent, or a side may be assigned. After the brief is submitted, participants begin preparing for their oral argument. The competition’s specific rules will determine the length of the brief, the time allotted for oral argument, and how many participants will speak. Each round of a moot court competition is presided over by a panel of “judges” . . . law students, law professors, practicing attorneys, or even actual, sitting judges. The judges ask questions during oral arguments, forcing participants to quickly change their train of thought, and to think analytically on their feet. Decisions are announced sometime after the oral arguments are concluded.
Both of us teach in West Georgia, far from moot court competitions. So we created our own. Developing a moot court competition takes time and effort. We designed the facts of the cases to be similar to several cases that the US Supreme Court had not decided before we argued them, changing only the plaintiff names and states or locales but keeping the core issues. These ranged from the death penalty and mental health, intrastate drug sales, the rights of Article II judges to publicly critique government policy, book bans, and how much pro-life clinics must disclose to their patients.
The Columbus State University Pre-Law Club partnered with LaGrange College to develop an inaugural moot court competition that provided students with an authentic appellate advocacy experience. Students spent the semester researching constitutional law cases, preparing legal arguments, and participating in structured practice sessions before presenting their cases in a federal courthouse before US Magistrate Judge Amy Helmick and, later, Superior Court and State Court Judges Nina Markette Baker and Wesley Leonard.
Local attorneys David Rayfield, Ed Berry, Chance Miller, and Will Yeiser volunteered as mentors for the CSU team, providing feedback on legal analysis, courtroom etiquette, and oral advocacy. For instructors seeking to build a similar program, one of the greatest successes was the involvement of practicing attorneys who provided real-world expertise and credibility.
Coordinating schedules among students, faculty, attorneys, and the court system proved challenging. Additional obstacles included accommodating students from varying academic backgrounds and levels of legal knowledge. We addressed these challenges through regular communication, standardized case materials, and multiple practice opportunities. Ultimately, we were able to provide meaningful experiential learning through the competition without a formal law school program when community partnerships and intentional planning are prioritized.
A key lesson for faculty interested in replicating this model is the value of broad collaboration. Rather than limiting participation to pre-law or political science students, Columbus State University recruited students from accounting, business, communication, criminal justice, history, and political science. This interdisciplinary approach strengthened case preparation by encouraging students to analyze legal issues through multiple lenses, including economics, public policy, communication strategy, and historical context.
The program also relied heavily on collaboration between Columbus State University and LaGrange College. Establishing common expectations, timelines, competition rules, and case assignments required ongoing communication between faculty advisors at both institutions. Additionally, partnerships with local attorneys and the federal judiciary provided professional mentorship and authentic evaluation. While coordinating multiple stakeholders occasionally created logistical difficulties, the collaborative structure became one of the program’s greatest strengths. The involvement of higher education institutions, legal professionals, and the judiciary created a network of support that enhanced student learning and reduced the burden on any single faculty member. This shared responsibility model offers a practical framework for other institutions seeking to establish sustainable moot court programs.
Participant feedback suggests that moot court competitions can serve as powerful tools for both student engagement and experiential learning. Students consistently reported that the opportunity to apply classroom knowledge in a real courtroom setting increased their confidence, professional skills, and interest in legal and civic issues. One participant noted, “I think events like the moot court competition is the best way to make people want to meet-up and be on campus more.” This observation highlights an oft-overlooked benefit of experiential learning: fostering a stronger sense of campus community.
Judges and attorney mentors expressed enthusiasm for the format and enjoyed discussing legal issues with participants. Their willingness to volunteer their time reinforced the value of community partnerships in educational programming. Students also emphasized the importance of faculty support and mentorship throughout the process.
For faculty considering a moot court program, feedback from participants suggests that authentic settings, professional engagement, and opportunities for meaningful interaction are critical components of a successful experience. The enthusiasm generated by the inaugural competition has already encouraged plans for future events and expanded partnerships.
Patrice Kerner is an assistant professor in the School of Policy, Justice, and Public Safety Columbus State University and brings a wealth of private sector experience to the classroom on subjects of law.
John A. Tures is a professor of political science at LaGrange College and chair of the program. He is also a newspaper columnist and author. He has been using in-class moot courts since 2021.
The post Building Your Own Moot Court for Undergraduates appeared first on The Teaching Professor.
