
Note: This is part 1 of a two-part series on how to assess the quality of different teaching methods.
We’re having the wrong debate about teaching methods, and this happens over and over again. Let me explain. For a long time now, the dominant approach to evaluating teaching methods has been what I’ve called the “best-practice approach,” which assumes that there exists a single best teaching method for all subjects, all teachers, and all students. If teachers follow this best practice, the logic goes, students will always and automatically learn. I’ve pointed out the flaws in this approach before, specifically that all learning is contextual. Learning emerges, if it occurs at all, from a complex interaction of multiple factors, such as the skill and knowledge of the teacher, the subject matter, and the characteristics of the students. Because learning depends on the alignment of multiple factors, there is no single best teaching method for all teachers, subjects, and students. There are no magic bullets in teaching; context makes all the difference. The effectiveness of any teaching method depends on how well teachers implement it. Any teaching method will fail when implemented inappropriately or in the wrong context. Teaching requires constant adaptation to what is happening in the class.
Yet the best-practice approach persists. As a result, teaching becomes fad driven. Some trendsetter touts a new method or technology as the key to effective teaching. The method becomes immensely popular, with reports of its instant success, then inevitably there are failures where the method doesn’t work in certain situations, and it falls out of favor, giving way to the next shiny new teaching fad. We’ve seen it with growth mindset, MOOCs, clickers, and flipped classrooms, to name a few. Teaching changes, but it does not improve. I’ve seen over a hundred such fads in the course of my career, some of which are the same practice with a different name.
I’ve seen the best-practice cycle firsthand. Back in 2000, my university received a major grant to implement problem-based learning (PBL), a form of inquiry-based instruction where, in lieu of traditional lecture, teachers give students challenging problems to explore on their own. It was the hot new method that would solve teaching. Enthusiasm among faculty for PBL was high because the grant brought opportunities for new equipment, release time, and stipends. I, however, was skeptical. I asked the PBL experts why this method was supposed to be better than others for student learning. What did this method do in terms of cognitive principles of learning that other methods did not? They couldn’t really answer, because the assumption was that if you just followed the steps, students would learn.
Part of the grant was to hold a major conference, and it attracted PBL advocates from around the world. I saw a pattern. If you did PBL and got positive results, that was great. If you tried it and got null or negative results, you either didn’t understand PBL or must not have implemented it correctly, because if you did, it would have worked. To its advocates, PBL was infallible. A student and I presented research we had done on PBL. We found that if students came across misinformation while exploring their assigned problems, they accepted it uncritically and retained the misinformation as well as the correct information. Our paper received a lot of critical pushback from attendees. They were not open to critical feedback.
PBL was developed and used in medical schools and engineering programs. Medical students are highly motivated and already have a strong foundation of knowledge. Engineering students deal with structured problems using well-established principles. A best-practice approach assumes that PBL should generalize to introductory liberal arts classes. It did not. Many faculty found implementing PBL in their classes to be deeply challenging. Students often objected to the method. PBL was especially problematic to new faculty because it required teachers to give constant feedback to students and make adjustments on the fly. New faculty lacked the experience to do so. Eventually, most faculty went back to their old teaching methods, with only a few faculty still using PBL as their major approach.
When I used to teach the required research methods course for psychology majors, I relied heavily on problem-based learning, but these were upper-level students who already had a foundation in psychology and were motivated to learn how to conduct psychological research. Using PBL makes sense in that context. And like most teachers, I didn’t rely exclusively on one teaching method; I combined PBL with other methods depending on the concept I was teaching. Growth mindset, MOOCs, clickers, and flipped classrooms can all be effective teaching methods when used in the right context.
I’ve seen this same dynamic play out with other “best practices.” Proponents can’t explain why a method is supposed to improve learning according to cognitive principles of learning. People who get null or negative results are dismissed as not really understanding the method or doing it incorrectly. Supporters of different approaches talk past each other.
Now I see this pattern repeating itself with a method called explicit instruction, which an influential group of educators is touting as the new best way to teach. In explicit instruction, the emphasis is on clear explanations and practice using concepts. The rising popularity of this method comes in part from the interest in the “science of reading” to address falling reading achievement and the “science of math” to address falling math achievement in children. I think there’s a lot to recommend in explicit instruction, but I also think it’s a mistake to promote it as a best practice. Inevitably, some teachers will implement it inappropriately, and there will be situations where it fails. Then explicit instruction will become at risk of being dismissed as yesterday’s fad when it turns out not to be the magic bullet of teaching.
If the best-practice approach is fundamentally flawed, what’s a better alternative? In my next essay, I propose a different approach.
Stephen L. Chew is a cognitive psychologist who endeavors to translate cognitive research into forms that are useful for teachers and students. He is the recipient of multiple awards for his teaching and research. He was a long-serving professor of psychology, now retired. Author contact: slchew@samford.edu.
The post We’re Having the Wrong Debate About Teaching Methods . . . Again appeared first on The Teaching Professor.
