You are currently viewing Every Class Is the Super Bowl: The Complexity of Predicting Learning and Winning

Every Class Is the Super Bowl: The Complexity of Predicting Learning and Winning

Even if you can’t tell a pigskin from pigs in a blanket, have no idea where the Seahawks or Patriots are from, or couldn’t care less who is playing in one of the most-watched sports events in the world—the Super Bowl—it’s hard to avoid the football hype in February. Prognosticators attempt to predict the outcome. Millions of Americans use the game as a chance to gather friends for scrumptious food fests. Many of us look forward to the expected jump in creativity of the expensive advertisements that accompany the game. For us teachers, football in particular (and sports in general) provides a key opportunity to reflect on the challenges of our jobs as educators, understand performance, and plan for success.

Predicting victory is difficult (go easy on yourself)

For most teachers, victory means getting as many students to learn as possible. Whether we have a class of 15 or 400, it’s natural for the caring teacher to want their students to “get it,” to understand the content, learn skills, and be engaged with the material. Just as the team that scores the most points wins the game, when students earn the most points they get an A grade. Unlike football, every student can win, but like football, it’s extremely difficult to predict which student will win.

The most common predictors of victory in sports relate to the skills of the players and the coach. Most dominant college athletes will probably have at least some success in the pros. Teams with experienced coaches are most likely to win more often. There are many more factors at play on any given Sunday the outcome can be different: Maybe playing at home will make a difference. Maybe the way the defenses matches the offense will make a difference. Teaching and success in class likewise have many different predictors.

Too often we teachers exclusively blame ourselves when our students do well. Perhaps we did not prepare as well, design our classes correctly, or be available enough. Some of us put the onus completely on the students. Perhaps the students did not read the book, come to class, or spend enough time testing themselves. Again, while any given class can have a different outcome—the same student may not do as well in all their classes, and the same teacher may not succeed in every class they teach—the most important fact for us all to remember is that there are many different factors predicting learning. In one of the best discussions of this point, Hattie (2015, 2023) combed through 2,100 summaries of studies, creating a meta-meta-analysis demonstrating that both teacher factors and student factors are important. Just as we shouldn’t blame only the quarterback or any of the other players for a loss, we also shouldn’t completely blame the coach either.

Great players are only part of the story

Most of the attention in football is on the quarterback and other key players. Just as an individual player’s mistakes draw a coach’s scrutiny, so students’ individual failures at learning draw ours. Of course, the players need to have skills and abilities, knowledge of the game, and familiarity with the different plays. They all must practice a lot. The story is the same for our students. They need to work hard at exposing themselves to the content (reading the book, coming to class and participating), but they also have to practice their skills and use optimal study techniques.

But learning, like football and sports, is not all on the player. There are numerous other factors that we must factor in. Sometimes external factors can greatly affect the extent to which students can focus. Even in the past six years, we’ve seen Americans grapple with major turbulence, ranging from a global pandemic to federal shows of force in major cities. Higher education faced the pandemic by changing a lot of what it did. We changed where we held classes and modified course delivery and assessment. The ways different universities adapted as they addressed the many factors influencing learning, with a focus on both the student and the teacher, was impressive (Gurung & Plaza, 2024).

Like good coaches, we teachers also need to be knowledgeable of our craft. We should know how to determine learning outcomes, design a course, create assessments, use the optimal instructional methods, be inclusive teachers, and adequately use technology, to name just a few critical elements of effective pedagogy (Gurung & Hammer, 2026; Richmond et al., 2021). In every football season you see many examples of how a strong coach can make the difference, and likewise, in many classrooms, our teaching like champs can help our students triumph at learning.

Leadership is important

In the first round of this year’s NFL playoffs, the Green Bay Packers played the Chicago Bears. In the first half, the Bears turned the ball over a few times, including on a costly interception thrown by their quarterback Caleb Williams. The Bears were down by 18 points at the start of the last quarter of play. As they did throughout the season, the Bears rallied and came back to win the game. While this outcome showcased the resilience of the players and their ability to bounce back from early failure (what we wish all our students can do when faced with a poor score early in the term), it also shone a spotlight on leadership. The quarterback led his team onward, rallying them together, but by all accounts the coach was the glue. What does the coach tell a player when they make a mistake? How does a coach react to a player having problems? The answer can turn the game around.

Many of our students will struggle. Some of them will commit major blunders, the equivalent of fumbling the ball when about to score or throwing an interception allowing the opponents to score (i.e., a pick-six). Sometimes this is due to insufficient practice or ability, but often it’s due to mental health or stress issues (Cavanagh, 2024). What we say to them, how we react, and the resources we provide them with can make all the difference.

The lessons we can learn from sports are manifold. I should also note that even if we are not big sports watchers, many of our students are. Many of our students care about whether the home team (college or otherwise) wins. Sports provide identity and, for our purposes as instructors, can also offer a way for us to talk to our students about the factors that influence success. The reality is that behavior is complex. Whether you are predicting learning or the outcome of a big game, many factors are involved. Using the parallel of football or sporting success with teaching and learning may be a refreshing way to discuss better techniques with our students. We may even be able to reflect on our own craft with new eyes.


Regan A. R. Gurung is professor of psychological science at Oregon State University. His latest books are Teach Like a Champ and Thriving in Academia. Follow him on LinkedIn.

The post Every Class Is the Super Bowl: The Complexity of Predicting Learning and Winning appeared first on The Teaching Professor.