You are currently viewing In Search of Joy in Teaching and Learning

In Search of Joy in Teaching and Learning

I was recently invited to write an essay about a pedagogy of joy, an approach to teaching that treats joy as part of learning. I had a visceral reaction and wanted to say, “No, thank you.” But I didn’t, even though I felt my body say it immediately. Instead of brushing it off, I wanted to sit with that feeling and investigate the source of my resistance. Generally speaking, I wouldn’t call myself a pessimist, although there are times when it’s hard not to be. But in higher education, I still have hope, and I still have many moments of joy. I am aware of the role of happiness in learning. A 2006 review article about the neuroscience of positive emotions indirectly supports the notion that positive affect, such as joy, plays an important role in how our attention, motivation, and memory—all of which matter a lot for teaching and learning—work.

But even if joy clearly matters for learning, what was the source of that resistance?

After further reflection, I realized that I was not resisting joy per se. I was resisting yet another shiny intervention. I am tired of our celebrating yet another new idea because it sounds hopeful while the conditions that make joy hard, or unevenly available, stay untouched. I found myself asking: Joy for whom? Joy at what expense? Joy to what end?

I most definitely want my students to experience joy in their learning and in their journey through college. In fact, in my syllabus for my human physiology class, I include on page one a statement about my wishing for my students to experience the joy of learning. I, too, want to experience that joy in my teaching and in my work with students.

But what does the joy of learning actually mean? And how do we achieve it?

I will be honest. This semester, I’ve had a tough, tough time. Burnout, moral injury, anxiety, wars, you name it. A few weeks ago, I almost ran upstairs to my department chair’s office and asked to take a leave of absence. I didn’t. I knew that would be too much for my department to handle and didn’t want to abandon my students. Instead, I talked with a colleague. She asked me what was it exactly that was making me feel anxious, sad, and depleted. My answer, immediately, was “truth telling.” It has become increasingly tough in the academy, and as I was describing it . . . I began to cry, and those tears, ironically, brought me a glimpse of joy.

How and why?

My colleague witnessed me without asking, “Have you tried ______?” In that moment, I felt a breath of fresh air. I recognized, too, a small moment of moral coherence, and that recognition made me feel alive and connected.

That moment, and writing this essay, forced me to rethink my still-evolving working definition of joy. If a glimpse of joy can arrive through tears, then perhaps the word cannot simply mean cheerfulness or classroom fun. Indeed, that moment felt quiet and physiological and offered me relief and reconnection to myself. To make more sense of what I had actually experienced, I turned to language so I could better understand how joy has been named and imagined.

Etymologically, the word joy traces back to Middle English, where it denoted “pleasure, delight, and bliss.” That didn’t give me lots of information. The equation of joy with pleasure is not what I had experienced.

Arabic doesn’t have a single one-to-one equivalent for joy. In Modern Standard Arabic, one finds multiple words that overlap but differ in tone and context, such as the following:

  • فَرَح (faraḥ)—joy or gladness; often outward and celebratory
  • سُرُور (surūr)—delight or joy; often calmer, “settled” gladness
  • سَعَادَة (saʿāda)—happiness and well-being; more enduring energy
  • بَهْجَة (bahja)—radiant delight; joy with brightness and beauty
  • اِبْتِهَاج (ibtihāj)—jubilation or exultation; active rejoicing
  • غِبْطَة (ghibṭa)—bliss or admiring happiness for someone
  • مَرَح (maraḥ)—high spirits; playful joy

What these all have in common is that they describe positive emotional states. Rather than simply collapsing those states into one universal “good feeling,” psychologists often describe positive emotions as varied states that shift across context and culture. This complexity of a positive state is why the literature treats emotions as co-occurring and terms such as “tears of joy” exist.

In the context of teaching and learning, that linguistic variation matters because joy in learning is not a single outcome we can add with a strategy. Instead, it is an emergent experience that context and conditions both shape. I find myself then asking not so much how I can make joy happen but rather whether the conditions I am cultivating (or not) make joy possible, uneven, or inaccessible.

In many traditions and writings outside Western education discourse, joy is rarely seen as a single emotion we can produce on the fly. Joy is a complex state that emerges when people have dignity, meaning, and room to breathe. In his Pedagogy of Freedom (1998), for instance, Paulo Freire suggests that joy is not a pedagogical tactic per se. It is, rather, a byproduct of ethical teaching. He describes the joy of truth-telling, of refusing the lie of omniscience, and of building and maintaining credibility through humility (p. 68).

But pedagogy alone did not fully explain what I had felt, so I then turned to human interiority and paradox. I turned to poetry. Kahlil Gibran wrote about joy and sorrow and in a way demystified the split between the two, inviting us to consider how they might be structurally linked such that our openness to one can deepen our capacity for the other. This joy and sorrow connection is more than a poetic relationship. I got to see that paradox in practice earlier this month.

I began a weeklong series of oral midterms for my physiology students. I meet with each student for 25–30 minutes. Last year, I started incorporating oral exams (or midterm conversations, as I refer to them in my syllabus) because they allowed me to hear how students were thinking through physiological processes and helped reveal levels of understanding that written tests often miss. As I sat with each of them, asking them to convince me that they had learned the materials, I could immediately tell how much they cared. Their nervousness was palpable, and it wasn’t due to a lack of preparation. I knew they had prepared. Many of them had studies for hours. I had watched some of them work through concepts in my office and over Zoom. I found myself feeling really nervous, too—for them and slightly for myself. I wasn’t nervous because I doubted them. I felt protective of what was at stake. How do I hold them accountable without making them feel embarrassed?

One of the questions on the exam was one they had to prepare themselves. They came up with it, they asked it, and they answered it. The question had to be something I didn’t cover on the study guide and demonstrate both sophistication of understanding and creativity. I make students ask questions because it requires them to move beyond recall and take intellectual ownership of the material. This was my favorite part of the midterm conversation because it allowed me to see their curiosity, originality, and vulnerability in a way no standard exam question ever could. It also enabled me to see something like joy take shape! I found myself wondering less about the content and more about whether they loved it and were enjoying learning. I wondered whether they felt that elevation that comes when we work hard and our work turns into understanding. I made sure to ask each of them why that question mattered to them and how I appreciate their ownership, curiosity, and creativity. In every single case, both the student and I wished we had more time to talk about their question. I felt that joy and I hope they did too.

A pedagogy of joy is not a single strategy nor series of strategies that feels good. It is the patient work of building the conditions for moral coherence, where we tell the truth with humility and curiosity, where we witness and experience being witnessed, and where we tend to and uphold each other’s dignity. That, to me, is what keeps a pedagogy of joy from becoming another shiny intervention, because we cannot demand or stage joy. It can emerge and endure through relationships and courage even and perhaps especially in the midst of burnout and injury.


Mays Imad is an associate professor of physiology at Connecticut College. Previously, she taught for 14 years at Pima Community College, where she also founded the teaching and learning center. She is a Gardner Institute Fellow for Undergraduate Education, an Association of American Colleges & Universities Senior STEM Fellow, a Mind and Life Institute Fellow, a scholar-in-residence at Georgetown University’s Red House, and a research fellow with the Centre for the Study of the Afterlife of Violence and the Reparative Quest (AVReQ) at the University of Stellenbosch.

The post In Search of Joy in Teaching and Learning appeared first on The Teaching Professor.