You are currently viewing God Save the Keen: Designing for Authentic over Artificial Learning

God Save the Keen: Designing for Authentic over Artificial Learning

Growing up, I was drawn to punk rock because it effectively expressed the angst I felt with things like curfews and homework, to say nothing of the raging hormones of being a teenager. I loved how it questioned authority with an unapologetic attitude. I now find my inner teen punk wanting to rebel against AI, and for many reasons: It has been forced upon me in almost every digital platform (often without the ability to opt out); it is a disaster for the environment; it is dulling critical thinking, cognitive liberty, and the art of the craft; it is a political project of massive corporate authoritarian handshake for power and wealth hijacking; it is “sloppifying” and demolishing every democratic institution originally built for public benefit. Regarding the shady ethics and morals in developing AI, even the Pope agrees (Leo XIV, 2026).

In the realm of higher education, AI is putting the transactional model of schooling on steroids: Speedy task completion in exchange for a credential reigns supreme over the slow, difficult work of intellectual formation. For those of us who teach online courses, where we used to get to know our students through their writing, it has become demoralizing to see the homogenization of AI-generated text in place of our students’ unique voices. But I don’t necessarily blame students. Most of them are merely trying to navigate and survive in this system (the university and the job market and society in general). And no matter how much we try to make our assignments “AI resistant,” particularly in online courses, this is proving to be a fool’s errand. Not only are educators stumbling through logistical hurdles of how to do assessment amid AI disruption and democratic upheaval, but we’re also simultaneously reckoning with a broader existential question: What is higher education actually for?

This question deserves serious deliberation and debate, especially since higher education has multiple purposes (some of which may be at odds). But if we are trying to get to the core of it, education is undoubtedly about learning and growth. Even before AI, there have been problems with how schooling doesn’t necessarily support those core tenets. A prime example is assigning grades, which have been shown to decrease student interest in the subject matter and tend to result in lower intellectual risk-taking (to get the easy A) and reduced quality of thinking (Kohn, 2011). If we want students to genuinely care about what they are learning, be intrinsically engaged in their learning, and be unafraid to challenge themselves, we would do well to rid ourselves of the artificial aspects of schooling, such as grades, that prevent authentic learning (learning for its own sake) from taking hold. Susan Blum (2024) rightfully calls out the game of school as “schoolishness” in her book by the same name. Performing school is not the same thing as authentic learning (Okker, 2026)

Anyone who has ever learned while engaged in a hobby or task that needed doing or in an informal setting like a book club or exercise class has experienced authentic learning. In his book How Humans Learn (2018), Joshua Eyler notes some of the characteristics of authentic learning, such as curiosity (the impetus for learning something); sociality (humans enjoy learning from and with other humans, and actually, our survival depends on it); emotion (how we initially interpret and process information); failure (making mistakes, learning through trial and error); and authenticity (working on problems, projects, or tasks that have real-world value outside of the classroom).

To design and teach our human learners in the age of AI, we need to center the authentic parts of learning over the artificial parts of schooling. We can do so on both a small and a large scale. On a small scale, individual instructors can examine their pedagogy, identify ways it constrains authentic learning, and replace those artificial structures with authentic learning opportunities. For example, to fan the flames of curiosity and encourage learning from failure, an instructor can remove grades or points attached to creative work so they don’t inadvertently discourage experimentation and intellectual risk-taking. This can also reduce fear, where grades and penalties drive effort, as well as the mindset of individualistic competition, which can discourage students from collaborating. Rather than designing assignments solely for their own eyes, which tend to reward compliance over creativity, often using a fixed rubric, instructors can give students opportunities to design their own (DIY) assignments that connect their learning to real-world audiences or problems. Then, together with students, they can codevelop evaluation criteria in partnership with them.

Beyond individual courses, instructors can work together to implement an alternative grading method for an entire program so students can have consistency in the grading approach used across courses. At my institution, we are piloting the use of alternative grading models such as specs grading in professional and continuing education courses with affirming results in student engagement, agency, and intrinsic motivation (Leslie & Gibson, in press). Once an entire program has success in moving to an alternative grading model, this can pave the way for institutional change on a large scale. Alverno College is a prime example of an institution that moved away from traditional letter grades and toward a more holistic, growth-oriented feedback model rooted in learning and improvement both for students and the university as a whole (Campbell & Meehan, 2017). This was accomplished mostly as a faculty-led initiative where professors replaced traditional letter grades with qualitative narrative feedback to facilitate authentic learning (for oneself; intrinsic) over performative learning (for others’ approval; extrinsic). Change begins with one class, one professor. But it can also have a ripple effect for an entire program, institution, or (ideally) higher education writ large.

One thing I learned from punk music is that it’s about staying true to yourself and not thoughtlessly following someone else’s agenda. Yet the way schooling is structured is one where arbitrary rules centering the institution over the learner often govern the day. For those of us who believe that teaching and learning are inherently relational endeavors, we have to “unschool” the artificial aspects of education that do not serve us in our humanistic quest for finding meaning, self-actualization, growth, and community—all things that cannot be reduced to a label, grade, score, or output. The significance of education depends entirely on the unique human person pursuing it and their own values, dreams, identity, and situated context toward a never-ending “destination unknown” (Rancid, 1995).

In the efforts to standardize and instrumentalize education, perhaps we have dehumanized the enterprise to the point that people don’t feel seen or respected as protagonists in their own learning or teaching, and now all we are left with is a simulacrum where students are using AI to complete assignments and instructors are using AI to grade assignments—a seamless, frictionless means to the end of the transaction. To revive education as a relational endeavor, I believe we need to weave the dignity of the human person with all their nuances, quirks, strengths, imperfections, and unique contributions into the fabric of the way a classroom functions, so that learners are respected for who they are, and who they are becoming. To resist the agenda of artificial is to fully embrace humanity in all its exquisite authenticity. “Hey, ho, let’s go!” (Ramones, 1976).

References

Blum, S. (2024). Schoolishness: Alienated education and the quest for joyful, authentic learning. Cornell University Press.

Campbell, C.M. & Meehan, M.J. (2017). Leading the call for improving student learning goals and outcomes. In J. Soto Antony, A.M. Cauce and D.E. Shalala (Eds.), Challenges in higher education leadership: Practical and scholarly solutions. Routledge.

Eyler, J. (2018). How humans learn: The science and stories behind effective college teaching. West Virginia University Press.

Kohn, A. (2011, November). The case against grades. Educational Leadership. https://www.alfiekohn.org/article/case-grades

Leo XIV. (2026). Magnifica humanitas: On safeguarding the human person in the time of artificial intelligence [Encyclical letter]. https://www.vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/en/encyclicals/documents/20260515-magnifica-humanitas.html

Leslie, H., & Gibson, A. (in press). Quality learning without penalty: An ungrading approach to support student mental health, agency, and engagement. Journal of Applied Instructional Design.

Okker, P. (2026, Janurary 23). The 5-letter problem with grades. Inside Higher Ed. https://www.insidehighered.com/opinion/views/2026/07/23/5-letter-problem-grades-opinion

Ramones. (1976). The Blitzkrieg bop!! [Song]. Sire/ABC.

Rancid. (1995). Ruby soho [Song]. On . . . And Out Came the Wolves. Epitaph.


Heather Leslie is an instructional designer, adjunct professor, and educational developer at the University of San Diego. She is passionate about designing and facilitating courses that center student agency, intrinsic motivation, and personal and professional growth.

The post God Save the Keen: Designing for Authentic over Artificial Learning appeared first on The Teaching Professor.