Teaching and learning scholars have widely recognized undergraduate research experiences (UREs) as high-impact practices that substantially influence student retention, learning, and professional outcomes (Lopatto, 2004; Williams & Xu, 2020). Though much research about UREs has focused on experiences in the sciences, UREs provide a foundation for all careers rooted in evidence-based practices, innovation, and reflection. As faculty, we continuously integrate UREs into our courses and programs, and students who have participated in these experiences indicate that UREs are not merely supplemental but transformative, providing a foundation for their professional lives.
To leverage this powerful tool, faculty must employ specific techniques to maximize student engagement and motivation. Our former students have indicated that the greatest benefits of participating in UREs related to their confidence and skills development, their grasp of perspectives in their field, their understanding of the research process, their understanding of how research applies to careers in their field, and opportunities to network with professionals in the field. From student responses and previous research in UREs, we developed three techniques to effectively integrate UREs into college experiences.
Technique 1: Cultivating transformative faculty-student mentorships
The quality of the relationship between the student and the faculty mentor is the single most critical factor in a successful URE. Ninety-two percent of our former students reported having had a highly positive experience with their faculty mentor. Students consistently cited connections with faculty as one of the most valuable aspects of their participation. To maximize the benefits of UREs for students, faculty should employ the following strategies.
Instrumental mentoring
Mentors must prioritize the explicit teaching of research skills, which Dominguez and Darrah (2024) term “instrumental mentoring.” This approach focuses highly on concrete skill development—such as statistical analysis, ethical methodology, and scientific communication—rather than expecting students to acquire these skills passively. This structured support is particularly important for students who may enter the URE with limited formal research training (Miller et al., 2022).
To implement this technique effectively, faculty should hold structured weekly or twice-weekly meetings where the agenda is organized around a specific research task, such as refining the literature review or practicing a data visualization technique. A practical, step-by-step strategy is to create a research milestone checklist to guide students sequentially through this process. This establishes realistic and measurable short-term goals and can help break what may seem an overwhelming process into manageable components.
Skill-gain communication
At the conclusion of the URE, a highly effective technique is to use a self-assessment or reflective approach to document skill development. Tools like the Survey of Undergraduate Research Experiences or Couse-Based Undergraduate Research Experiences surveys can provide quantifiable data, while a qualitative approach like Ripple Effects Mapping (Keaver et al., 2023) can be useful for helping students articulate the unintended positive outcomes, or “ripples,” of their experience. This allows students to formally recognize and internalize gains in self-confidence and self-esteem.
Technique 2: Expanding accessibility through diverse research models
To be maximally beneficial, UREs must be accessible and inclusive to a diverse range of undergraduate students. The traditional one-on-one apprenticeship model, while effective, can create barriers due to limited faculty resources (time, equipment) and students’ lack of research preparedness or established faculty connections (Miller et al.). To truly function as a high-impact experience that engages a diverse range of future teachers, UREs must adopt flexible models that broaden participation.
Course-based UREs
One way to enhance student experiences is through course-based research. Whether students are assigned a broad topic or given an opportunity to develop their own topic ideas within a course, faculty can provide undergraduate students with opportunities to develop important research skills, such as developing a research question, learning about previous research, and learning about current measurement or creative techniques in their field.
Collaborative cohorts
While most of our students completed independent projects, a small percentage participated in faculty-student collaboration models. Shifting the dynamic from strictly independent projects to collaborative cohorts allows faculty to manage larger projects while providing scaffolding and peer support. To implement this model, faculty can create research cohorts where multiple students contribute distinct but interconnected components to a larger project. This collaborative structure fosters a sense of peer support and teamwork (Taraban & Logue, 2012) and mimics the collaborative nature of a school-based professional learning community.
Technique 3: Fostering the teacher-researcher mindset
The most profound impact of the UREs on future professionals is the cognitive shift from learning about their field to applying techniques and practices in their field. Faculty should design UREs so students apply a theoretical concept to a real-world problem. Authentic learning should include a hands-on cycle of research, practice, and reflection.
Mandatory reflective synthesis
While conducting research develops analytical skills, students need a structured mechanism to consciously connect their specific tasks back to the broader profession. To achieve this, faculty could move beyond the traditional academic research paper and require a “Translational Memo” or professional brief instead. This would require that the student answer a question such as, “How do the ethical considerations, methodological decisions, or theoretical frameworks I explored during this research project inform my future decision as a practitioner in my field?” This ensures that the student recognizes the direct applicability of their decision on daily professional actions.
Concluding remarks
The URE serves as a high-impact mechanism for engaging and motivating future educators not only by fostering active learning skills but also through an intentional professional identity transformation (Van Eseltine et al., 2022). By structuring programs around three key techniques, institutions can maximize the reported student gains in self-confidence, self-esteem, and understanding research applicability. Ultimately, transforming undergraduate research from an elective pursuit into a foundational component of the college experience is essential for preparing effective, data-literate or critically minded professionals for their future careers.
AI disclosure: The authors confirm that they performed all data collection, analysis, literature review, and initial drafting. They used Google Gemini solely for organizational and structural recommendations about the manuscript content. The authors reviewed and approved all elements and are fully responsible for the final submission.
References
Dominguez, K., & Darrah, M. (2024). The impact of multiple research experiences on undergraduate students. Research in Higher Education Journal, 45, 1–23. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1444112.pdf
Keaver, L., Ludy, M.-J., Folk, S. Y. L., Gadd, S., Oleksiak, M., Hsiao, P.-Y., & Tucker, R. M. (2023). Use of Ripple Effects Mapping to assess student-perceived benefits of undergraduate research and learning objective attainment with Irish nutrition students. Advances in Physiology Education, 47(2), 194–201. https://doi.org/10.1152/advan.00043.2022
Lopatto, D. (2004). Survey of undergraduate research experiences (SURE): First findings. Cell Biology Education, 3(4), 270–277. https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.04-07-0045
Miller, C. T., Drewery, M., Waliczek, T. M., Contreras, R. N., & Kubota, C. (2023). Engaging undergraduate students in research. HortTechnology, 33(1), 1–7.https://doi.org/10.21273/HORTTECH05130-22
Taraban, R., & Logue, E. (2012). Academic factors that affect undergraduate research experiences. Journal of Educational Psychology, 104(2), 499–514.https://doi.org/10.1037/a0026851
VanEseltine, M., Coty, V., Van Noy, M., & Owen-Smith, J. (2022). The research premium: Undergraduate research experiences and early employment [Manuscript]. Institute for Research on Innovation and Science, University of Michigan. https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/4dxze_v1
Williams, D. J., & Xu, T. (2020). Perceptions of research: Comparing pre-service teachers with other majors. TxEP: Texas Educator Preparation, 4, 81–90. https://www.csotte.com/_files/ugd/c33c67_8510243c99304516b7dc2a13cf272c97.pdf
Suzanne F. Lindt is a professor and chair of the Department of Undergraduate Education at Midwestern State University. Her research focuses on motivation and engagement in K–12 and higher education, and she has mentored undergraduate students on numerous research projects.
Sarah M. Straub is an associate professor in education studies at Stephen F. Austin State University, specializing in culturally responsive pedagogy, social studies, and multicultural education. Her interdisciplinary training informs qualitative research on identity and equity. Straub’s work with NAME, humane education, and community outreach advances inclusive, transformative learning for diverse student populations.
The post Engaging and Motivating Students Through Undergraduate Research Experiences appeared first on The Teaching Professor.
