You are currently viewing Teaching When Listening Comes First: What I’ve Learned About Engagement in Indigenous-Serving Classrooms

Teaching When Listening Comes First: What I’ve Learned About Engagement in Indigenous-Serving Classrooms

Faculty training in higher education often emphasizes verbal participation as the primary indicator of student engagement. In graduate preparation, instructors learn to value quick interaction, frequent discussion, and other visible forms of participation. An “active” classroom commonly means one in which students speak often. Over time, these expectations become the norm and shape course design, participation policies, and judgments about teaching effectiveness.

These assumptions, however, do not hold across all cultural contexts. When instructors enter classrooms where learning expresses itself in other ways, established definitions of engagement may fail to capture how students are actually learning.

Listening as a central mode of learning

When I began teaching at an Indigenous-serving institution, I encountered classrooms where students listened attentively but rarely initiated or responded to questions publicly. Learning unfolded in a deliberate and steady manner, one characterized by close attention to lectures, careful note-taking, and thoughtful completion of assignments. Initially, I perceived this quietness as a lack of engagement.

Over time, I came to understand that what was missing was not student involvement but alignment between my academic training and students’ culturally grounded approaches to learning. In these classrooms, listening functioned as an active intellectual practice rather than a passive one.

When we misinterpret silence

In many Indigenous cultures, learning emphasizes observation, careful listening, and respect for the wisdom of elders (Barnhardt & Kawagley, 2005; Castagno & Brayboy, 2008). They often regard instructors as elders who guide students through experience and knowledge. Speech is often intentional rather than spontaneous, and people demonstrate understanding through reflection and integration over time (Castagno & Brayboy; Pewewardy, 2002). These norms are familiar to Indigenous students but often not so to faculty who have trained within Western academic traditions.

Because instructors are rarely taught to recognize listening as a form of engagement, quiet classrooms may seem to signal disengagement, confusion, or lack of preparation. Early in my teaching career, I shared these assumptions and attempted to address perceived disengagement by encouraging spontaneous discussion or filling silences quickly. In doing so, I overlooked evidence that learning was already occurring.

Shifts in participation over time and trust

As I gained experience and became a familiar presence in the classroom, participation patterns shifted naturally. Some students began to respond more openly during class, not as a result of increased pressure to speak but through the gradual development of trust.

Despite these changes, broader patterns remained consistent. Younger Indigenous students were less likely to initiate questions during lectures, whereas older adult students and white students were more likely to speak publicly. These differences reflect cultural norms regarding respect for elders and appropriate timing for speech (Castagno & Brayboy).

Rethinking engagement

An important pedagogical shift involves broadening definitions of engagement beyond verbal participation. In listening-centered classrooms, engagement is often evident through sustained attention, detailed notes, and strong integration of course material across assessments. Students who speak infrequently during class often demonstrate deep understanding when given opportunities to reflect and respond in writing.

In my courses, some of the quietest students consistently produce the most analytically sophisticated written work. Their papers reflect careful synthesis of lectures and readings, even if they rarely speak during class discussions. When instructors prioritize only the forms of participation they have been trained to expect, they risk overlooking substantive learning.

Evaluation practices are particularly consequential in this context. Both informal judgments about effort and formal grading criteria can unintentionally reward talkativeness rather than comprehension. Attending carefully to how we define and assess engagement helps ensure that we evaluate students on the basis of learning outcomes rather than speaking frequency.

Teaching practices that support listening-centered classrooms

Teaching effectively in Indigenous-serving classrooms requires intentionality rather than reliance on assumptions. Several instructional practices have proven especially effective:

  • Purposeful use of silence. For many Indigenous students, speaking is a deliberate act rooted in a reflective learning style. They tend to pause and consider options to ensure an answer is known for certain before responding (Pewewardy). Consequently, allowing silence provides students with time to think and signals respect for these Indigenous norms.
  • Structured participation opportunities. Open-ended prompts—such as “Any questions?” or “Who wants to jump in?”—often privilege students who are already comfortable speaking spontaneously. Clearly structured prompts and guided discussion questions create more equitable entry points and emphasize thoughtful contribution.
  • Valuing delayed and written responses. Learning doesn’t always occur in real time. Written assignments and online discussion spaces often reveal levels of understanding that are not apparent through classroom discussion alone.

Examining instructional norms

Most teaching practices reflect the cultural contexts in which faculty were trained. Participation requirements, grading rubrics, and classroom routines often assume a particular style of verbal engagement that faculty have come to treat as universal. Recognizing that these norms are culturally situated is not about framing Indigenous students as needing accommodation. Rather, it involves acknowledging that Western academic practices represent one set of cultural assumptions among many.

When instructors critically examine these assumptions, teaching shifts from habit to reflection and from standardization to responsiveness.

Conclusion: Learning from the classroom

Teaching Indigenous students has required me to slow down, recognize listening as a form of engagement, and confront assumptions shaped by my graduate training. These lessons extend beyond Indigenous-serving institutions. As higher education classrooms become increasingly diverse, instructors are more likely to encounter students whose learning styles do not align with dominant academic norms.

Effective teaching in these contexts depends on attentiveness, flexibility, and willingness to learn from students. Sometimes the most important pedagogical shift is a simple one: allowing teaching itself to listen before it speaks.

References

Barnhardt, R., & Kawagley, A. O. (2005). Indigenous knowledge systems and Alaska Native ways of knowing. Anthropology & Education Quarterly, 36(1), 8–23. https://doi.org/10.1525/aeq.2005.36.1.008

Castagno, A. E., & Brayboy, B. M. J. (2008). Culturally responsive schooling for Indigenous youth: A review of the literature. Review of Educational Research, 78(4), 941–993. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654308323036

Pewewardy, C. (2002). Learning styles of American Indian/Alaska Native students: A review of the literature and implications for practice. Journal of American Indian Education, 41(3), 22–56.


Yuqing Zou is an assistant professor of psychology at the University of New Mexico–Gallup. She earned her PhD in psychological and quantitative foundations from the University of Iowa. Her research focuses on social-contextual and motivational factors related to students’ academic outcomes, and her teaching interests include applied psychology, social psychology, general psychology, and statistical analysis.

The post Teaching When Listening Comes First: What I’ve Learned About Engagement in Indigenous-Serving Classrooms appeared first on The Teaching Professor.