You are currently viewing Centering Creativity Everywhere in Teaching and Learning

Centering Creativity Everywhere in Teaching and Learning

Creativity scholars Kaufman and Glăveanu (2019) argue that “like love or happiness, creativity is everywhere and nowhere in academia” (p. 27). They make this claim within the context of scholarship, stating that while everyone has an opinion, creativity can be difficult to define and categorize.

The first time I read this quote, I thought about the visibility and invisibility of creativity in higher education. Those of us who work on college campuses know that we stand at the epicenter of idea generation, problem solving, and novel thinking. We also know that we’re living in a political climate that questions the relevancy of higher education, forcing us to reckon with our role as disseminators of inherited knowledge or professionals on the cutting edge of originality. Our students are familiar with these conversations. They recognize that disciplinary competence won’t be enough to guarantee success in a world competing for the next big thing. Knowledge of subject matter alone is no longer prized as a mark of accomplishment. Instead, students need to be prepared to use their foundational proficiency to think critically, problem solve, and innovate in order to succeed in their chosen fields. If we want to support our students in developing these skills, we need to embed opportunities to be creative everywhere in our courses.

Defining and categorizing creativity

Definitions of creativity traditionally stress elements of “new” or “novel” in combination with “value” or “usefulness” (Walia, 2019). The concept of novelty, however, is a challenge when it is positioned within the context of the classroom. As students engage in the process of learning, it’s unlikely that they will contribute anything truly novel to their field of study, especially at the undergraduate level. Instead, Kaufman and Beghetto (2009) argue for a classification of “mini-c” creativity, which they define as ideas or products that are personally meaningful for the creator. Mini-c is the type of creativity learners are most likely to display within a classroom setting and is therefore of central concern for teachers who wish to support their students’ creative development. It’s essential that teachers recognize this initial spark of creativity and take steps to nurture its growth.

Value and effectiveness are where disciplinary context comes in. For something to be creative, it has to have value within the accepted parameters of the field. A car with square wheels may be novel, but not many would value its mobility. This is where students depend on us as experts to offer feedback on the appropriateness of an idea or product within the existing body of knowledge.

Creative teaching and teaching for creativity

In addition to our recognizing and nurturing instances of mini-c creativity, students also need us to establish the conditions under which creativity can occur. Offering such support requires us to use our expertise and creativity in the design and instruction of our courses. Scholars generally view creative teaching behaviors in two ways: teaching with creativity and teaching for creativity. Teaching with creativity involves “teachers using imaginative approaches to make learning more interesting, exciting, and effective” (NACCCE, 1999, p. 102), with an emphasis on creativity in designing and teaching lessons (Lin, 2014). A creative teaching approach draws on novel instructional strategies that generate excitement, pique curiosity, and—most importantly—put us in the position to model the creative skills of our discipline. Teaching for creativity, by contrast, “focuses more on the objectives and strategies of developing learners’ creative capacities” (Lin, p. 44). When we teach for creativity, we focus on the behind-the-scenes work of setting up experiences and experiments that will support students in developing their own creativity through learning, thinking, and participating in the authentic work of the discipline. Since creative teaching and teaching for creativity often occur simultaneously, they initiate a cyclical relationship in which the teacher’s creativity inspires the students’ creativity and vice versa.

Small steps to center creativity

Fostering students’ creativity does not necessitate an extensive overhaul of our syllabi, lesson plans, or assessments. Centering creativity in our courses can begin in smaller ways by implementing the following strategies:

  1. Position creativity as an expectation. There is moderate evidence to suggest that simply telling students to “be creative” may result in more original ideas (Wei et al., 2024).
  2. Embed creativity into course introductions or icebreakers. Begin the semester by encouraging students to think, rather than listen, by posing a thought-provoking question, introducing an unsolved problem in your discipline, or sharing a fact that peaks curiosity.
  3. Offer choice in the way students demonstrate knowledge. Think beyond the term paper or comprehensive exam. We can maintain control over the skills we want students to demonstrate and the criteria we want students to meet while still allowing for autonomy in the finished product.
  4. Encourage divergent thinking by posing open-ended questions. Provide students with opportunities to think through the current problems in the field. Challenge them to revisit these questions throughout the semester as they acquire more content knowledge. Existing problems are ones that field experts have yet to solve, and sometimes a fresh perspective can reveal solutions.
  5. Help students to be comfortable with failure. Share an article or a book proposal you wrote that was rejected (I’m sure we all have some humbling feedback from Reviewer #2!). Creativity requires trial and error, often over and over again. Students, however, typically only meet those who have achieved success in a discipline and miss the backstory of the steps it took to get there. Creativity isn’t always about the finished product; honor the process.
  6. Prioritize feedback over grades. A fear of earning a low grade reasonably disincentivizes students from taking the risk that being creative requires. Allow students to submit smaller chunks of the major course assignments and receive feedback from you or their peers before you formally evaluate the work for a letter grade. Reward original thinking over the regurgitation of information from the lectures or textbook.
  7. Remember that being creative is a vulnerable process. It takes courage to put new ideas out into the world, especially when you are a novice in the field. Model your willingness to accept this risk by sharing your own creative work with your students, especially works in progress. When students take a risk in showcasing their own creative work, go out of your way to offer praise and acknowledgement.

We have the opportunity to make creativity more visible and to use the content of our discipline to support students in their own creative development. This begins with a reconsideration of our instruction and assessment with a concern for embedding creativity everywhere in our practice and expectations.

References

Kaufman, J. C., & Beghetto, R. A. (2009). Beyond big and little: The Four C model of creativity. Review of General Psychology, 13(1), 1–12. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0013688

Kaufman, J. C., & Glăveanu, V. P. (2019). A review of creativity theories. In J. C. Kaufman & R. J. Sternberg (Eds.), The Cambridge handbook of creativity (2nd ed., pp. 27–43). Cambridge University Press.

Lin, Y.-S. (2014). A third space for dialogues on creative pedagogy: Where hybridity becomes possible. Thinking Skills and Creativity, 13, 43–56. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tsc.2014.03.001

NACCCE, (1999). All our futures: Creativity, culture and education, national advisory committee on creative and cultural education. London: DFEE. https://sirkenrobinson.com/pdf/allourfutures.pdf

Walia, C. (2019). A dynamic definition of creativity. Creativity Research Journal, 31(3), 237–247. https://doi.org/10.1080/10400419.2019.1641787

Wei, X., Shen, W., Long, H., & Lu, F. (2024). The power of the “be creative” instruction: A meta-analytical evaluation. Learning and Motivation, 85, 101945. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lmot.2023.101945


Joanna Weld is a faculty fellow in the Department of Teacher Education at Niagara University. She holds a PhD in curriculum and instruction from the University at Albany and her research interests include creative pedagogy, creativity in secondary teacher education, and practitioner research.

The post Centering Creativity Everywhere in Teaching and Learning appeared first on The Teaching Professor.