You are currently viewing Active Learning: Engaging Students in Deep Thinking

Active Learning: Engaging Students in Deep Thinking

This essay appears in The Teaching Professor Conference: The Best of 2026 (Magna Publications, 2026). Learn about next year’s event here.

Active learning has a long history in higher education, with Bonwell and Eison’s (1991) influential report helping its rise to prominence in the early 1990s. Today, active learning remains a popular concept in college teaching. But what exactly do we mean when we use the term?

There are many views of what learning is and how it happens. One inclusive description of learning is that it is a process that leads to change (Barkley & Major, 2018). What that change is can vary. The change can involve acquiring content knowledge, developing a new skill, seeing the world in a new light, or other.

Whatever the change is, making it happen requires cognitive work on the part of the students. And as instructors, we can choose instructional strategies intentionally to support the process. Indeed, promoting and supporting learning is part and parcel of the job; as Angelo and Cross aptly suggested, “teaching without learning is just talking” (p. 3).

When we think of “active learning,” we often think of instructional activities, such as think-pair-share or jigsaw. Over time, the term has become associated with instructional activities rather than the cognitive processes that those activities are intended to support. The challenge with this perspective is that an emphasis on activities can obscure and even undermine the fundamental goal of instruction: helping students learn through sustained and meaningful mental effort and engagement.

Active learning, however, is fundamentally about the quality and depth of students’ thinking. Most instructional activities we ask them to complete can require active learning. Our task, then, is to make intentional choices about teaching activities that promote and support deeper levels of thinking relevant to the intended learning.

Redefining active learning: From activities to mental effort

My colleague Elizabeth Barkley and I have described active learning as the level of mental effort students put into their learning (Barkley & Major, 2018). What we mean by this is that cognitive engagement is itself more important than the outward apparent effort. Critically, we note that not all mental effort is equally productive. Thus, the challenge for the instructor is not simply to choose activities that increase the amount of effort (which can be done via busywork) but instead to choose activities that encourage students to direct their efforts toward cognitive processes that support intended learning.

We also argue that learning activities do not predetermine the levels of thinking involved. This view challenges the common assumption that students are necessarily cognitively passive when listening to a lecture. Indeed, students can engage in substantial mental effort while listening, including investing attention, analyzing arguments, noting agreement or disagreement, and monitoring understanding and developing questions. Whatever activity we assign can engage students in basic-level cognitive processes or more complex ones.

See the following table for examples of levels of cognitive effort for several different instructional activities.

Activity Basic Cognitive Processes More Complex Cognitive Processes
Listening Identifying facts Evaluating arguments and monitoring understanding
Problem solving Applying a familiar procedure Recognizing structures and evaluating approaches
Reading Locating information Constructing meaning and evaluating ideas
Discussion Reporting information Evaluating perspectives and developing arguments
Writing Describing concepts Synthesizing, critiquing, and creating

Table 1. Examples of cognitive processes across common learning activities

Choosing instructional strategies to support active learning

The challenge is for instructors to assign activities that can produce the kind of learning they intend and then create conditions that promote and support active learning within those activities. Thus, active learning techniques (instructional activities) can support active learning (mental effort and engagement).

Activity Sample Technique Technique Description How It Leads to Active Learning
Listening Analytic Teams Each team member assumes a different role with specific responsibilities to perform while listening to a lecture or watching a video. Students listen, analyze information from a preassigned perspective, and evaluate ideas.
Problem solving Case Studies Students review a real-life problem scenario in depth. Students apply concepts, analyze complex situations, and evaluate alternative solutions to real-world problems.
Reading Active Reading Documents Students complete a carefully prepared question set to use while reading. Students actively interpret, question, and evaluate what they read while monitoring their own understanding.
Discussion Jigsaw Students work in expert groups to learn one part of a larger topic, then return to their home groups to teach what they have learned. Students learn, organize, and explain information and deepen their understanding by teaching their peers.
Writing Paper Seminar Students participate in a structure process for meaningful discussion centered on student writing. Students critically evaluate their own and others’ writing, articulate their reasoning, and refine their thinking through discussion and feedback.

Table 2. Sample techniques to promote active learning

Simply using one of these activities does not guarantee deep thinking. Instead, success depends on how instructors structure the activity, set expectations, ask questions, and so forth, all of which influence the student experience and the mental effort learners willingly expend.

Evidence supporting active learning

A substantial body of research supports the efficacy of active learning in improving learning outcomes. In their now classic meta-analysis of 225 studies, Freeman et al. (2014), for example, found that undergraduate STEM students who learned in courses supported by active learning had higher performance on exams and lower failure rates than those who learned through lecture alone. These findings reinforce the importance of intentionally designing for cognitive effort.

Conclusion

Learning requires mental effort. Active learning means that students are engaging at a high level of mental effort. Viewing active learning as the depth and quality of mental effort and engagement rather than a specific instructional technique offers a new perspective for thinking about our work as instructors. The central question for instructors, then, is not simply whether students complete a learning activity but whether the activity helps them think deeply about what it is that they need to learn.

References

Angelo, T. A., & Cross, K. P. (1993). Classroom assessment techniques: A handbook for college teachers (2nd ed.). Jossey-Bass.

Barkley, E. F., & Major, C. H. (2018). Interactive lecturing: A handbook for college faculty. Jossey-Bass/Wiley.

Bonwell, C. C., & Eison, J. A. (1991). Active learning: Creating excitement in the classroom (ASHE-ERIC Higher Education Report No. 1). The George Washington University, School of Education and Human Development. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED336049

Freeman, S., Eddy, S. L., McDonough, M., Smith, M. K., Okoroafor, N., Jordt, H., & Wenderoth, M. P. (2014). Active learning increases student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111(23), 8410–8415, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1319030111


Claire Major is a professor of higher education and the faculty director of the Teaching Academy at the University of Alabama. Her work focuses on teaching, learning, and technology in higher education.

The post Active Learning: Engaging Students in Deep Thinking appeared first on The Teaching Professor.