You are currently viewing Arguing with AI: How Interactive Avatars Transform Difficult Conversation Practice 

Arguing with AI: How Interactive Avatars Transform Difficult Conversation Practice 

A business major must tell a teammate their work is jeopardizing a project. A nursing student listens as a patient hesitates, clearly withholding something important. A new professional struggles to push back against an unfair workload. These moments arise in different fields, yet they share a common thread: Each demands calm, clear, and well-practiced communication in situations charged with emotion or uncertainty. 

Students will face conversations like these long before they feel ready for them. Traditional simulations help, but they are often limited by scheduling, space, and staffing. To offer scalable, flexible opportunities for practice, we need new methods. AI avatars provide one such path, giving students a safe and repeatable way to rehearse high-stakes dialogue. 

What argumentative avatars are and why they support learning 

AI avatars use advanced technologies like natural language processing, voice recognition, and real-time rendering to simulate people with complex emotions and motivations. Unlike scripted bots, these avatars are carefully designed by humans (e.g., instructional or simulation designers) to respond authentically to student input. This approach creates engaging, realistic practice opportunities that support learning in new and meaningful ways. 

  1. Anywhere, anytime practice:These simulations can occur with or without a human facilitator, in person or virtually. 
  2. Authentic communication practice: AI avatars respond like real people would and respond to what students contribute to the conversation. 
  3. Repetitive practice: Students can easily start a conversation over or be given multiple attempts. 
  4. Immediate, personalized feedback: AI avatars can be trained on rubrics that align to the learning objectives. If students ask for feedback, the avatar can deliver it. 

The possibilities across disciplines are promising. In a business context, for example, an avatar might play an employee who is about to be fired. In nursing, an avatar might portray a worried family member questioning a discharge plan. In any case, students practice listening, empathizing, clarifying, and responding thoughtfully. Repeated, realistic dialogue strengthens these skills. 

Example 

This video demonstrates an interactive AI avatar simulation created in HeyGen. In this scenario, a student practices navigating a difficult workplace conversation with a supervisor. To build the simulation, we provided the avatar with a backstory, role-specific context, and key information; however, the conversation itself is unscripted. The avatar responds dynamically based on the context it has been given and the end-user’s choices throughout the interaction.

This type of simulation may represent an important next step in developing interpersonal and professional communication skills because it more closely approximates the complexity of real-world conversations. Notice how the avatar’s voice, mood, and tone shift throughout the exchange as John works to resolve the situation.

There are limitations with this technology. For one, the avatar’s facial expressions and body language lack emotion. This weakens the realism of the interactions and can be distracting to the end-user. There are also concurrency limits (the number of people that can access the avatar at one time) and time limits for each conversation. Future product updates promise to address these issues, and given the rapid evolution of this technology, we hope to see these updates soon.

The future of AI avatar technology is bright. It allows learners to have authentic, on-demand conversations to build interpersonal skills across a wide array of learning scenarios and disciplines.

Steps for designing effective avatar conversations 

There are five main steps to creating an avatar. 

  1. Identify communication skills to target. These are the learning objectives of the simulation. 
  2. Build the avatar. First, choose an avatar. Most programs provide a wide variety of Aesthetics and voices to choose from. Then write a description of the avatar. Include their profession, how they will behave, their personality, and their communication style (including sample language). Next, provide background knowledge on the scenario. The more information you provide at this stage, the more realistically the avatar will perform. Finally, test the avatar by conversing with it.
  3. Provide a feedback mechanism (e.g. rubric) for the avatar to evaluate the student’s performance.
  4. Prep students with preliminary information before the simulation. This might include a link to the simulation, learning goals, and role the student will play.
  5. Require reflection or discussion after the simulation to deepen learning. 

Integrating avatar conversations into class activities 

There are numerous ways to incorporate interactive avatars into classroom learning, allowing for flexible and engaging practice: 

  • Individual practice sessions for students to rehearse challenging conversations 
  • Paired or team reflection activities to discuss strategies and outcomes 
  • Peer-reviewed conversations, where students provide feedback to each other 
  • Recorded avatar interactions for grading or self-assessment 
  • Group debriefs for students to share insights and lessons learned 
  • Embedded avatar simulations within course modules or assignments 

These approaches help students build communication skills in a variety of formats, supporting both independent and collaborative learning. 

Common pitfalls to avoid 

When designing a simulation and an AI avatar, the following will decrease the efficacy of the learning experience:

  • Not giving the student enough information about the role they are playing in the scenario
  • Not giving the AI enough information, context, or behavioral cues
  • Not providing a rubric for actionable feedback
  • Skipping reflection or debriefing with students 

In our experience, extensively testing the AI avatars can help illuminate design flaws. It’s important to make corrections prior to student participation in the simulation.

Teachers needn’t abandon live role-play or other well-established modalities of simulation. Instead, we offer another tool to the simulation toolkit. Interactive AI avatars can provide safe spaces for students to practice difficult conversations, develop emotional intelligence, and enhance learning. The future of education may lie in creating authentic, emotionally engaging experiences that prepare learners for real-world challenges, and AI avatars represent a promising step toward this personalized, adaptive learning.


John Bellotti III and Becca McLagan are instructional designers at the University of Wisconsin–Oshkosh.

The post Arguing with AI: How Interactive Avatars Transform Difficult Conversation Practice  appeared first on The Teaching Professor.