
The recent report from Harvard College on grade inflation (Claybaugh, 2025; hereafter “the report”) is an important reminder of how complex grading is and the many ways it can go wrong. The report focuses on grade inflation, but negative outcomes of poor grading systems include inhibiting learning, undermining achievement, reinforcing inequality, and causing undue stress (Anderson, 2018; Eyler, 2024). The report raises several issues about grading that apply to all academic settings.
My first critique of the report is that it never defines grade inflation. The report is clear that the percentage of A grades has greatly increased in recent years, going from 24 percent of all grades in 2005 to 60.2 percent in 2025. But is that grade inflation? The definition matters. I define grade inflation as a comprehensive upward shift in course grades over time without a corresponding increase in actual learning. The report makes clear the upward shift has occurred, but what about the second part? Are the students also learning more? On that point, the report is unclear. There is a critical distinction between teaching that makes it easy to get high grades and teaching that makes it easy for students to learn. The former is grade inflation. The latter is skilled teaching. All too often, we conflate the two; we assume any increase in grades must indicate grade inflation.
The report states that Harvard initiated a program to improve teaching in 2007 and “many of us have redesigned our courses to increase learning” (p. 9). That suggests that the grade increase might reflect better teaching, but the next few paragraphs undercut that notion due to how they discuss grading. There is a lot of confusion about the definition of grading. In their classic book, Effective Grading, Walvoord and Anderson (1998) provide the following research-based description of the grading process:
Grading includes tailoring the test or assignment to the learning goals of the course, establishing criteria and standards, helping students acquire the skills and knowledge they need, assessing student learning over time, shaping student motivation, feeding back results so students can learn from their mistakes, communicating about students’ learning to the student and to other audiences, and using results to plan future teaching methods. (p. 1)
In other words, grading is not simply the evaluation of an end product. It is a complex process in which assessment and evaluation are tied to learning goals that are tied to learning activities. The grading system sets the standards for learning and performance, provides meaningful feedback to both students and teachers, and allows students to improve their learning and teachers to improve their teaching during the course.
Given that definition of grading, consider some of the other aspects of the report. The faculty became more aware that students arrive at college with different levels of preparation and that many of them are dealing with significant external stresses. The report states the following about the faculty response: “Unsure how best to support their students, many have simply become more lenient” (p. 9). That is a short-term solution that leads to grade inflation and ultimately shortchanges students who take more advanced courses. A more difficult but better solution is to provide students with various ways of demonstrating learning, multiple evaluation opportunities, and supplemental instruction through online modules for those without adequate prior knowledge.
Next, the report notes that many faculty have followed a national trend toward alternative grading systems such as specifications grading or “ungrading.” The report notes that
many of us shifted from high-stakes exams to more frequent lower-stakes assignments, believing that this would help students retain the material. A number have found, however, that lower-stakes assignments are more effective at rewarding effort than at evaluating performance, giving students the false sense that they’d mastered material that still eludes them. (p. 9)
I believe the report is stating that students could complete the low-stakes assignments without learning or mastering concepts. That points to problematic grading. Effective grading means tying assessments to learning goals. If the low-stakes assignments do not add up to learning mastery, then the assignments need revising.
Finally, the report states that alternative grading approaches may allow more students to make high grades, but that is “fundamentally at odds with our current grading system, which relies on grades to differentiate” (p. 9). In other words, the high preponderance of As does not allow for differentiation or sorting of students into different ranks or categories. Note, though, that the definition of grading discusses evaluation against a standard, but it never mentions sorting or differentiation. One can have meaningful evaluation without differentiation if everyone does well or poorly. What is important is that the grades reflect learning. If students are learning, it isn’t grade inflation.
Let me use my senior-level cognitive psychology course as an example. I give high-stakes exams in which I provide a study guide for students that includes about 40 identification items and 10 high-level essay questions. Students have about 10 days to prepare their answers. Good answers for the terms require a thorough understanding of the concepts, and for the essays they require an understanding of relevant research that students organize into a persuasive answer. Students are free to ask me questions and work in groups. On the day of the exam, I pick four of the identification items and two essays for students to answer. To do well, students must have mastered the concepts, but this is a senior course mostly made up of psychology majors and minors. Most everyone is capable of doing well if they put in the effort. On the final exam, over 70 percent of the class got As. Is that grade inflation? I would say no because the grades reflect learning. The grades do not differentiate among the As, but all the students were capable of achieving a high level of learning, so differentiation does not make sense.
Harvard’s solution to grade inflation was to mandate an upper limit of 20 percent of students who could receive A grades. I’ve explained in detail why this is the easy, wrong solution. Meaningless differentiation is not better than no differentiation at all, and sometimes there is no meaningful differentiation among students. Training faculty in effective grading systems and requiring them to show evidence that their grades reflect actual learning is far more difficult to do than imposing arbitrary grade limits, but it would differentiate between grade inflation and skilled teaching
References
Anderson, L. W. (2018). A critique of grading: Policies, practices, and technical matters. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 26(49). https://doi.org/10.14507/epaa.26.3814
Claybaugh, A. (2025, October). Re-centering academics at Harvard College: Update on grading and workload. Office of Undergraduate Education, Harvard University. https://ouedocumentlibrary.fas.harvard.edu/sites/g/files/omnuum1616/files/2025-10/Update_on_Grading_October.27.2025.pdf
Eyler, J. R. (2024). Failing our future: How grades harm students, and what we can do about it. Johns Hopkins University Press.
Walvoord, B. E., & Anderson, V. J. (1998). Effective grading: A tool for learning and assessment in college. Jossey‑Bass.
Stephen L. Chew is a cognitive psychologist who endeavors to translate cognitive research into forms that are useful for teachers and students. He is the recipient of multiple awards for his teaching and research. He was a long-serving professor of psychology, now retired. Author contact: slchew@samford.edu.
The post It’s Not Grade Inflation If Students Are Learning appeared first on The Teaching Professor.
