You are currently viewing Should It Stay or Should It Go? The Practice of Giving Students Slides

Should It Stay or Should It Go? The Practice of Giving Students Slides

“May I have your slides, please?” If you’re not an instructor who posts their class slides online, you’ve undoubtably heard this question. Should you make your slides available? One answer is, “It depends.” As with most pedagogical questions, there are many nuances indeed. But after considering the high levels of faculty stress and low levels of student engagement in higher education today, I have a clearer, bolder prescription: Just say no. Don’t stop there either. Share your reasoning.

We make many choices when we teach. We select learning outcomes, choose assigned readings, decide on assessments, and then plan our instructional methods. The effectiveness of our pedagogical choices on student learning depends on a number of factors. Some of the usual suspects are educator and student characteristics, the discipline we teach in, course size and modality, and the course level; there’s also how we lecture, how much we put on our slides, and our choice to share them or not. Regardless of whether you distribute your slides, be sure that you’re intentional (let students know that you will or won’t), transparent (let them know exactly why or why not), and compassionate (if you won’t, recognize that many students will be disappointed).

On the surface, the reasons that tend to accompany the opening question may seem sound. Perhaps the student worries about gaps in their notetaking and wants to make sure they’re not missing important points. Maybe they believe that having the slides will help them pay more attention to you than when they’re furiously transcribing your ever word. Copies of your slides may help students who struggle to catch everything you say whether because the course is in their second language or they otherwise cannot mentally process your words at the same pace as others. A student may have a disability that requires an accommodation. These last issues represent real individual differences and are candidates for exceptions to a flat no.

What about the evidence? I’m becoming more watchful about when studies were conducted: before the pandemic began or after. The pandemic years of emergency remote teaching, when many instructors at all education levels recorded lectures and provided full access to slides, probably changed student expectations in a way that continues to influence their requests (although students did want slides before the pandemic too). When you see evidence that both supports and opposes giving slides out, the time of the study may be important, but other contextual factors such as context, timing, and the type of course all play a part. I tease apart many of these below.

In one study, for example instructors varied when they provided slides. When they gave slides before lectures and didn’t require attendance, attendance rates were higher than when students received slides after class. The timing of providing slides did not affect exam scores (Babb & Ross, 2009). By contrast, another study showed that when students received slides before lecture, they did better on a final test and spent less time studying for it (Marsh & Sink, 2010).

Some evidence suggests that sharing slides provides students with more time to think about the material and highlight what is important and that the slides help students take better notes and listen more to instructor (Chen & Lin, 2008). At the same time, making slides available can be distracting, cause confusion, diminish attention, and hurt note-taking and the coding of new information (Kiewra, 1989). In one of the most thorough studies of giving out slides, researchers examined student behavior over two semesters and compared three slide conditions. Students received partial slides, full slides, or no slides at all (Worthington & Levasseur, 2015). Those who were given any slides did worse on exams and also took lower-quality notes than those who did not. Taking notes during class correlates with better exam scores, and taking time to train students on how to take good notes is important (Gurung & Dunlosky, 2024; Haynes et al., 2015). Just giving students slides or notes is not a great solution if students do not know how to use them well and in fact reinforces poor study behaviors (Pardini et al., 2014).

Many studies use naturally occurring groups for ethical purposes, comparing students of instructors who give slides with students of instructors who do not. But few completely experimental studies have used the same instructor for both groups. In one of my favorites, not only did the instructor both distribute slides and withhold them, but she also did so during the same semester (Noppe, 2007). She gave one section of the course slides for one exam and a final. The other section received slides only for the final. Both sections had 50 students. The group that received slides whether for the exam or final did worse and shared that having the slides made them concentrate less during class. These results question the efficacy of slideshow handouts for student learning outcomes.

More recent research supports these findings (Perez-Lopez et al., 2022). For example, in one study, 173 students either received slides before class or did not. Having the slides had a negative impact on students’ learning and attendance (Leon & García-Martínez, 2021). Speaking of attendance, some research does suggest that having slides does not negatively affect attendance (Grant & McGrath, 2023) and increases inclusivity for students with ADHD and learning disabilities, student athletes, and those who cannot attend.

Slides and notes can vary in clarity, complexity, and length, so a blanket prescription is difficult to test. Whether you decide to give out slides or not, aim to use evidence-based practices to make your slides effective (Mayer, 2014; Strauss et al., 2014). Especially if you believe that students should be accountable for their learning and need to put in effort, having them take their own notes from your slides is an easier decision. Add to that the reality that taking notes will help them pay attention and focus on class, especially as doing so will mean spending less time on phones or nonacademic websites. The data does bear this out. Limiting access to notes has no deleterious effects on learning and may prompt more attention and better note taking (Grant & McGrath).

You can see that there’s research on both sides of the decision, though the recent work suggests fewer benefits to providing slides and stands to provide a vehicle to reengage students in our classes. Even if we’re open to students taking a look at our slides in our offices or with teaching assistants (or even giving slides in special cases, such as for accommodations), a practice I support and use, training students how to take notes from our slides will undoubtably serve them in the long run. It does mean we don’t talk too fast, don’t zip through slides, or pack slides with too much information. It may also mean you directly address the how of note-taking in class, especially if it’s an introductory class with first-year students not socialized to college. Once you’ve satisfied these conditions, you’ll find that not giving out slides can become the pedagogically sound new normal.


Regan A. R. Gurung is professor of psychological science at Oregon State University. His latest books are Teach Like a Champ and Thriving in Academia. Follow him on LinkedIn.

The post Should It Stay or Should It Go? The Practice of Giving Students Slides appeared first on The Teaching Professor.