You are currently viewing Teaching Students to Teach Themselves: A Two-Phase Approach to Self-Regulation

Teaching Students to Teach Themselves: A Two-Phase Approach to Self-Regulation

What if the most powerful teaching tool wasn’t a new AI technology but humans helping other humans become teachers themselves? After two decades working with neurodiverse students who think differently, are brilliant, and struggle academically, I’ve discovered that the combination of metacognitive problem-solving instruction and peer mentorship creates a definitive pathway to self-regulation. It’s surprisingly simple to implement and scalable in a way that is transformative for students, classrooms, and institutions.

The challenge: Moving beyond content delivery

We’ve all seen it: students who can analyze facts and drive a class discussion but can’t regulate their own learning to write a coherent paper. Inversely, there are those other students who can write but can’t analyze and who bring little more than a memory for facts to a discussion. Both types of students struggle because no one has taught them how to identify and solve their own learning problems. Traditional instruction focuses on what students should learn, but rarely addresses how they can take ownership of their learning and developmental process.

One group of students who find this approach especially beneficial are those diagnosed with learning disabilities. These students often arrive with years of remediation, but little understanding of their own complex learning patterns. They often lack the confidence to apply what they have learned in a meaningful way that enables them to succeed. What these students need isn’t more content instruction but to become experts at addressing their own educational impediments.

Phase one: Teaching metacognitive problem-solving

The foundation of this approach is deceptively simple: Teach students to think like scientists about their own learning. Instead of being passive recipients of strategies, students learn to generate, test, and refine their own solutions.

I start by asking students a single question that changes everything: What problems are you facing in your learning, and how might we solve them together?

This question does three things. First, it positions students as partners rather than passive learners. Second, it acknowledges that learning challenges are problems to be solved, not fixed deficits. Third, it opens a collaborative conversation about their specific needs.

Once students identify a learning problem— whether it’s academic (e.g., organization, time management, reading comprehension) or interpersonal (e.g., social and psychological impediments)—students can apply the same basic approach:

  • Make a prediction. What needs to happen to manage this problem better?
  • Test it. Create a strategy you can track for a couple weeks.
  • Reflect and adjust. What works, what’s improvable, or what should you abandon.

This cycle mirrors how scientists work, and more importantly, it mirrors how humans naturally learn. Research shows that whether you are a young child, college student, or tenured professor, you use the same predict-test-revise process to understand the world (Bonawitz et al., 2012). We’re not teaching students something foreign; rather, we’re formalizing a natural problem-solving process they already possess.

What makes this powerful is the metacognitive component. Students are not merely implementing strategies I give them but are developing them with my support, directing their awareness of how they learn and are building the skills to continuously adapt. I guide them to notice patterns: When does this strategy work? When does it fail? What does that tell you about yourself as a learner?

Phase two: Learning through teaching others

Here’s where the approach becomes fundamentally restorative: Once students develop metacognitive problem-solving skills, they become mentors to peers who are just beginning their journey.

In Curry College’s Program for Advancement of Learning (PAL), founded by Dr. Gertrude Webb as the first college level program to support college students with learning disabilities, students learn to metacognitively investigate their unique learning differences. There I worked with Dr. Maria Bacigalupo as part of the PAL mentorship program. These students helped their peers organize and complete assignments while reframing their learning differences as unique strengths and gifts.

That observation led to a revelation: Having students mentor others reinforced their own learning while providing authentic leadership opportunities for students from backgrounds that traditional academic settings have historically marginalized.

The mentorship structure is straightforward:

  • Pair strategically. Match students who have developed specific self-regulation skills to share with peers beginning their metacognitive journeys.
  • Focus on process, not content. Mentors are not simply there to help with homework. Instead, they share their problem-solving processes: “When I’m overwhelmed . . . ,” “I used to struggle with that too,” “Here’s what I do first,” and so on.
  • Meet regularly. Even 15–20 minutes weekly makes a difference. The consistency matters more than duration.
  • Debrief with mentors. This is critical. I meet with mentors to discuss what they’re noticing, what questions they have, and how they’re adjusting their approach. This reflection deepens their metacognitive awareness.

The impact: Beyond individual students

The results consistently surprise me. Mentors often show greater gains in self-regulation than their mentees. Why? Teaching forces them to articulate their thought processes, strengthening metacognitive awareness. They also gain confidence and identity as capable learners. These are powerful experiences for students who previously saw themselves as academically deficient.

For mentees, having a peer who understands reduces stigma and increases engagement. A mentor who struggled with similar challenges provides both hope and concrete examples of success. The relationship becomes a safe space to experiment with new approaches without fear of judgment.

Perhaps most remarkably, this approach transforms classroom culture. Over time, metacognitive conversations about learning become the norm. Students start discussing strategies, sharing solutions, and supporting each other’s growth without prompting.

Implementing this in your classroom

You don’t need special training or resources to begin. Start small:

  • Identify candidates. Look for students who respond positively when asked about their learning challenges. These students are ready to engage metacognitively.
  • Begin the conversation. Use that opening question and work through the predict-test-reflect cycle together.
  • Create mentorship opportunities. Once a student shows consistent self-regulation, invite them to share their knowledge with a peer. Frame it as a leadership opportunity, not a tutoring assignment.
  • Support the relationship. Check in regularly with both mentors and mentees. Guide without controlling. Your role shifts from direct instruction to facilitating their problem-solving partnership.

Why this matters now

Our students face unprecedented challenges to self-regulation. Algorithmic systems have become ubiquitous across an individual’s life, from school, to social media to buying a stick of gum at the store. These systems are being designed to understand and influence behavior. So while these computer-based programs can offer tremendous supports to struggling students, they also enable teachers and administrators to apply unhealthy levels of monitoring and academic pressure on students before they have learned to regulate their behavior in response to these demands. Teaching students to become metacognitively aware problem-solvers provides essential protective skills for navigating the new academic and digital environments we are constructing.

More importantly, this approach honors students’ capacity for growth and leadership. When we invite students to collaborate in solving their learning challenges, and then to share that knowledge with others, we’re not just improving academic outcomes, we are facilitating genuine transformative learning that extends far beyond our classrooms.

The simplicity of this framework is its strength. You can begin implementing it tomorrow with a single student. Ask the question, guide the problem-solving process, and watch as your students discover they have the capacity to become authors of their own learning journeys.

References

Bonawitz, E. B., van Schijndel, T. J., Friel, D., & Schulz, L. (2012). Children balance theories and evidence in exploration, explanation, and learning. Cognitive Psychology, 64(4), 215–234. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cogpsych.2011.12.002

Chen, C.-H., & Yang, Y.-C. (2019). Revisiting the effects of project-based learning on students’ academic achievement: A meta-analysis investigating moderators. Educational Research Review, 26, 71–81. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2018.11.001

Hulbig, P. R. (2023). The pedagogy of self-authorship: The neurocognitive impact of science and metacognition. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland.

Karcher, M. J. (2005). The effects of developmental mentoring and high school mentors’ attendance on their younger mentees’ self-esteem, social skills, and connectedness. Psychology in the Schools, 42(1), 65–77. https://doi.org/10.1002/pits.20025


Phil Hulbig is a senior lecturer in the Program for the Advancement of Learning at Curry College, where he specializes in metacognitive education for neurodiverse learners. His book, The Pedagogy of Self-Authorship (Springer, 2023), explores how metacognitive instruction supports self-regulation across diverse student populations. He has presented his work at national and international conferences and continues to develop innovative approaches to student-centered learning.

The post Teaching Students to Teach Themselves: A Two-Phase Approach to Self-Regulation appeared first on The Teaching Professor.