
A senior colleague mentioned to me recently that he had spent the early part of his career overcoming the idea that “teaching is telling,” a common and pernicious misconception, especially among new teachers. The phrase refers to the belief that the key to effective teaching is explaining a concept in just the right way. In other words, there exists some way to explain a concept that is so potently clear and accessible that students will always comprehend and learn it. The goal of the teacher is to find that explanation, tell it to students, and project it on a slide. After that, learning becomes the student’s responsibility. If the students don’t understand, then the teacher just needs to repeat the explanation until they do. The research is clear, however, that the existence of any such magical explanation is a myth. Effective teaching is much more than telling.
Clear and accurate explanations are certainly valuable, but they do not guarantee learning on their own. The Cognitive Challenge Framework (Chew & Cerbin, 2021) describes many factors that affect student learning that are not related to giving good explanations. Here are some of those factors.
Mental mindset refers to students’ beliefs and attitudes toward the class and topic. It plays a critical role in determining whether students will pay attention to your explanation or whether they will think it worth learning. Many factors make up mental mindset. Are the students teachable? In other words, do they recognize both the value in what you are teaching and the gaps in their own understanding? Are they sufficiently curious about the subject matter? Curiosity gives students the motivation to make the effort needed to learn the material. Although curiosity is a trait that varies among students, an effective teacher can create a state of curiosity about the concepts they are teaching that can motivate otherwise uninterested students to learn.
Do students trust you as a teacher? Do they believe that you are competent in both your knowledge of the subject matter and your abilities as a teacher, that you will act with integrity in your teaching, and that your top priority is helping everyone in the class to learn? Students who trust you will pay more attention to you and work harder for you. Students who see you as dogmatic, judgmental, and an obstacle to their success will not learn from you. Students should see that you as a highly trusted and reliable source of information. You have to be better than AI, YouTube, and other resources they could use to learn the information.
Students have to have sufficient prior knowledge to understand what you are explaining to them. Otherwise, you might as well be speaking a foreign language. But just having prior knowledge is not enough. You must activate the relevant prior knowledge in students before you teach the new concepts. Students may possess relevant prior knowledge, but it is only helpful when appropriately primed for use. Furthermore, the prior knowledge that students have may contain inaccuracies and misconceptions. Deeply held, intuitive misconceptions can interfere with learning more accurate information.
Finally, students have to use effective learning strategies as they study, or they will quickly forget the information. Most students prefer to use the least effective study strategies, which yield overconfidence but little long-term learning. Using poor study strategies is one of the main ways that students can fool themselves into believing they have mastered concepts when they really haven’t.
As an example of how ineffective “teaching is telling” can be, consider what happened on Southwest flight 1830 on April 17, 2018. In midflight, one engine exploded and debris crashed through a cabin window, causing depressurization.[1] Emergency oxygen masks immediately deployed, but few people actually put them on correctly. A photo from the flight showed that people failed to cover both their noses and mouths or failed to tighten them around their faces. Before every flight, flight attendants explain and demonstrate how to use the oxygen masks. Some of the passengers on that flight had probably seen the demonstration hundreds of times in many different variations. They probably were certain they knew how to put on the masks and so they stopped paying attention to the demonstration, but their actions showed that they had not really learned the proper procedure. Effective teaching is much more than telling.
[1]. Tragically, one passenger was killed, but the pilot managed to land the plane safely.
Reference
Chew, S. L., & Cerbin, W. J. (2021). The cognitive challenges of effective teaching. The Journal of Economic Education, 52(1), 17–40. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220485.2020.1845266
Stephen L. Chew is a professor of psychology at Samford University. Trained as a cognitive psychologist, he endeavors to translate cognitive research into forms that are useful for teachers and students. He is the recipient of multiple awards for his teaching and research. Author contact: slchew@samford.edu.
The post Teaching Is Much More Than Telling appeared first on The Teaching Professor.
