
“Let’s pretend,” I said, pointing toward the back row, “that Macbeth’s enemy is way across the battlefield, back by Jon.” I moved down the aisle, reciting Shakespeare’s language. “Like valour’s minion carved out his passage—till he faced . . .”—then gestured in the same direction as I finished the line: “the slave.”
The room chilled. Students shifted in their seats. My mouth went dry as it registered: Jon was the only Black student in the room.
And I had just called him a slave.
What do we do when we get it wrong—really wrong—in the classroom? When we say something unforgivable? When we ourselves become the source of injury in the very space we’re charged with protecting?
I wish I were asking from a safe distance, but I’m not. Despite my most conscientious efforts to teach with care, I’ve made significant blunders in the classroom. I’ve mispronounced students’ names, mishandled controversial texts, and realized too late that an off-the-cuff quip has done damage. I’ve used an example on the fly and then winced as it reinforced the very stereotype I was trying to critique. I’ve asked students to recite passages only to remember too late that they preferred not to read aloud in class. And I’ve watched in horror as students stiffened and withdrew from discussions after I accidentally misgendered them.
These mistakes—like the Macbeth one from nearly two decades ago—still haunt me, largely because I know the toll they can take on students. Gender and intersectional microaggressions can damage mental health, contribute to alcohol-related problems, undermine academic self-efficacy, and create a “chilly climate” that leaves students feeling unwelcome in, even pushed out of, entire fields of study. In the classroom, affected students often respond with disengagement, silence, and discomfort. For transgender students in particular, the harm can deepen further, alienating them from peers, tokenizing them, and forcing them into the exhausting work of educating professors and classmates.
Scholars have offered several acronyms—ACTION, ASSIST, ARISE, CARES, GRIT, RAVEN, VITALS—to guide us in the minutes, hours, and days that follow harmful speech in the classroom. But what I found myself most ill-equipped to handle were those face-flushing, stomach-dropping first few seconds. I needed an acronym that was simple enough to cut through the panic. Enter SNAP.
Stop
This step is the hardest because my first impulse is usually to plow ahead. Maybe no one noticed. Just keep going. Don’t make it awkward. Momentum is seductive; it can convince me that if I just keep talking, I can outrun what I’ve done.
Part of this instinct is physiological. In my panic, I can feel my body lunging into action before my mind has fully caught up: Attention narrows, breathing turns shallow, and the pressure to act intensifies. A brief pause interrupts that cascade.
For me, stopping also checks the performative impulse that usually leads to the mistake. I’ve committed some of my worst lapses because I confused theatricality with good teaching. The Macbeth incident, for example, arose from my attempt to make the scene feel immediate and alive on a hot August afternoon; I got swept up in the moment and let it override my judgment.
So I need the sheer force of that word, stop, to cut through my instinct to keep going. The pause need not be elaborate—the quicker, the better:
- “I need to slow down here.”
- “Hang on, I want to stop there.”
- “I’d like to put the brakes on for a moment.”
- “Let’s regroup for a second.”
- “Let’s step back briefly.”
- “Wait, please. Let’s ground ourselves for a minute.”
Name the harm
Research on harmful speech in the classroom is clear: The least effective response an instructor can choose is to ignore it. When teachers continue as if nothing happened, students often interpret that silence not as neutrality but as indifference—or even tacit approval.
Naming dispels that ambiguity so the burden of interpretation doesn’t fall only on the student(s) most directly affected. Bystander theory research on classroom microaggressions suggests that observers look to authority figures for cues about what just happened, how serious it was, and whether it deserves a response. If the instructor is also the one who caused the harm, that burden becomes heavier still: Was that acceptable? Did anyone else hear it the way I did? Is the person with the most power in the room willing to name what just happened? We need to put the transgression into specific language:
- “That framing was biased.”
- “I interrupted you.”
- “That example reinforced a stereotype.”
- “I put you on the spot.”
- “That joke was inappropriate.”
- “My gesture was harmful and insensitive.”
Apologize
A brief “I’m sorry” will suffice here; the real challenge is resisting the impulse to justify, explain, or soften what just happened.
In other words, don’t handle it the way I did with Macbeth: “Wait, I should clarify. In Shakespeare’s usage, slave can mean rascal or wretch. It’s a general insult and doesn’t carry the same sense it does in modern usage.” If I could just explain the line well enough, I thought, maybe I could contain the damage.
But I only made it worse by committing what researchers call a secondary microaggression: a response to the initial offense that compounds the original injury. Forms include denial (“That’s not what happened”), condescending explanations (“Let me tell you what that really means”), suggestions that the student is overreacting (“I think you’re reading too much into this”), and simply saying nothing at all.
The point is not to rescue our intentions but to own our impact.
Pivot
After we stop, name the harm, and apologize, the class still needs somewhere to go. We need to articulate clearly and concretely what will happen next:
- “Let’s take two quiet minutes before we go any further with this scene.”
- “I want to make space for a brief quiet pause before we return to the passage. Let’s write for three minutes.”
- “I’m going to redirect us to Macbeth’s characterization here.”
- “We’re going to stop a little early today, and I’ll stay afterward if anyone wants to talk.”
- “Let’s pause for a moment and decide together how we’d like to proceed.”
- “You’re free to stay, take a break, or follow up with me afterward. Please do what you need to do to take care of yourself in this moment.”
A clear pivot does not erase the harm, but it can help safeguard against compounding the damage.
SNAP is my reminder not to flee the moment I most need to face. If I am asking students to stay present through difficulty, then I must be willing to do the same when the difficulty begins with me. Care, after all, is not the absence of failure but what we summon in its wake.
Nichole DeWall is a professor of English at McKendree University in Lebanon, Illinois, where she teaches Shakespeare, medieval and early modern literature, drama, and composition courses.
The post Say Something Harmful in Class? SNAP Out of It appeared first on The Teaching Professor.
