You are currently viewing On Being an Ethical and Relevant Educator

On Being an Ethical and Relevant Educator

We teach who we are.
—Parker J. Palmer, The Courage to Teach

In many classrooms right now, silence has become palpable. It may look like disengagement, exhaustion, anxiety, resistance, uncertainty, or some combination of these. This past semester, in one of my courses, I would ask the class an open-ended question about the day’s materials and wait for someone, anyone, to raise their hand. But nothing. Silence. Two years ago, that kind of invitation would have drawn many students to raise their hands. Talking with colleagues across the country, I see that many of us are working harder to invite our students to speak, and many of us are wondering whether the old explanations for student disengagement still hold. Is this about attention? About AI? About loneliness? About the future students imagine, or cannot imagine, for themselves?

That uncomfortable silence has sharpened a question I suspect many educators are also asking: What does it mean to be an educator right now? More specifically, what does it mean to be an ethical and a relevant educator who cultivates meaningful and sustainable learning in what seems like a moment of unbounded loneliness and anxiety?

I do not pose this question because I have solved it. I pose it because the question itself seems like an honest place to begin. As Vanessa Machado de Oliveira writes in Hospicing Modernity, “Modernity also conditions us to avoid, escape, or want to be rescued from discomfort” (p. 109). To sit with a question we cannot yet answer, then, may be the first thing we can do to better understand this moment. If our students are struggling to connect, to find meaning and relevance in what they are learning, then our task is not simply to make them participate, comply, or show engagement. Our task is to ask what kind of teaching might meet and tend to this moment.

In this essay, I will focus on the first half of the question: What might it mean, now, to teach ethically and relevantly?

To begin, we might break the question down. If silence, anxiety, loneliness, technological change, and students’ uncertain sense of the future are reshaping teaching, then the desire to be ethical and relevant is not just personal. That aspiration names a larger struggle many of us are facing: how to respond to students as they are now without abandoning our expectations and commitments that make education worth pursuing in the first place.

Parker Palmer writes that “we teach who we are.” I have repeated that statement hundreds of times, and the longer I sit with it, the less it feels like reassurance and the more it feels like a question, or two questions, really. Who is the self that teaches: not the version in my syllabus but the one my students encounter on a Wednesday evening when no one speaks? And what am I teaching when the content seems to land on no one—what passes between us in the silence, the disappointment, the hope? My question begins here, with the desire to be an ethical and relevant educator, and I want to interrogate each of these terms.

Why ethics?

As I have written before, teaching is rarely, if ever, a neutral transfer of information. I recently reread Paulo Freire’s Pedagogy of the Oppressed with my research students. They devoured it. They were quoting from it left and right. When I asked why it resonated, most of them simply said that it “makes sense” and that they felt seen. Throughout the book, Freire reiterates and reminds us that educators hold power. We make choices that affect our students’ dignity, access, confidence, identity, sense of hope and responsibility, and future possibilities. The decisions we make in the classroom always have ethical weight. And given the power we hold, what choices do we need to be making to meet the moment and to help our students become more fully human, capable, free, and conscientious?

Which ethical principles should guide that power and those choices? Which are nonnegotiable? As both a scientist and a humanist, I think first of truth-seeking, truth-telling, and justice. Many of us want students to view education as a means of pursuing reality honestly, even when that reality is uncomfortable. Toward this end, we might ask: Are we helping students question carefully and distinguish reliable evidence from noise? Are we being honest about the world, our disciplines, the limits of knowledge, and the stakes of what we are study? Those stakes differ across fields, and they are rarely self-evident; part of our work is to name them. This honesty feels especially important because we and our students are surrounded by misinformation. Truth-seeking, then, requires more than assigning content. In my own classes, it has meant assigning less and deliberately limiting the reading and homework so I can design moments in which students slow down, examine evidence, and sit with uncertainty.

My mentor in Senegal, Dr. Erick Gbodossou, often reminds me that there is a difference between knowledge and knowing. And this distinction is one I associate with the Persian poet Rumi, who wrote about outer and inner intelligence. In Coleman Bark’s rendering of his poem “Two Kinds of Intelligence,” Rumi contrasts acquired knowledge with a knowing that arises from within. Through my intentional pausing and in those slowed-down moments, my hope is for information to turn into inner knowing. I hope students learn to seek and tell the truth beyond correct information and to move from knowledge to knowing, from outer to inner knowing.

I often think about my classroom and the power I hold and wonder whether the classroom is inflicting wounds or imparting hope and repair. Am I reproducing larger social inequalities? Or, even incrementally, helping bend the arc ever closer toward justice? I even find myself reflecting on who benefits from and who bears the burden of my choices. If truth is about investigating and understanding, justice is about speaking that truth and acting on it.

Beyond truth and justice, I want my pursuit of ethics to be motivated by love rather than anger or self-righteousness. I recently reread All About Love, where bell hooks writes that “we would all love better if we used it as a verb” (p. 19)—if we understood and treated love as action rather than feeling and so took on its accountability and responsibility. Here I think of another nonnegotiable: compassion, which is not about lowering expectations or easy As but about holding accountability in one hand and dignity in the other. What worries or burdens might this or that student be carrying? How can we respond to what they bring in a way that upholds their dignity and vulnerability while challenging them and supporting their growth?

Truth, justice, and compassion ground my purpose for teaching. And yet they are incomplete; it is hard for me to speak about ethics without bringing in another, fourth principle that has been foundational to my upbringing and the kind of person I seek to be: the Sufi concept of adab. It’s hard to accurately translate the meanings of adab (أدب), an Arabic term used across Islamic and Persianate ethical traditions. Roughly, we might think of adab as spiritual longing or courtesy, as working toward refinement and doing right by “others” both living and inanimate. Someone with adab displays great humility toward the world and acts with a deeply humane and cultivated moral sensibility.

In my classroom, acting with adab means holding students accountable without arrogance and without embarrassing them. I think of the students who have gone quiet on me this year. I have caught myself wanting to call on one of them directly and let the silence that follows do its disciplinary work. Each time, I stop myself. I owe that restraint to my father, who once told me, “I am too embarrassed to embarrass others.” And turning toward adab would mean to treat that silence not as defiance to be corrected but as something I do not yet understand. I had read withdrawal where there was exhaustion. Students are not problems to be managed, nor is knowledge my property to dispense; accountability without arrogance means holding them to the work while refusing to shame them for a struggle I cannot see. Adab, for me, means approaching even silence with humility and asking what it might be trying to teach me—considering what forms of dignity, beauty, or longing might still be there even when a student’s engagement is not readily visible.

With compassion and adab, ethics is not just a set of rules to follow and enforce but a beautiful way of being—a praxis to recognize the proper place, dignity, and beauty of everyone and everything around me.

Grounding my approach to teaching in truth, justice, and compassion, and my desiring to do so with adab, helps inform my quest to become an ethical educator. But ethical teaching alone is not enough, at least according to how I have formulated the question that informs this exploration of teaching in our current times.

Why relevance?

Relevance implies that something is both pertinent to the current context and useful—that it provides the information we actually need. But relevant to whom and for when? Of course, we want to impart relevant knowledge, thinking, and skills to our students, who can then bring what they learn to their communities and society as a whole. In addition, I would wager that most of our students feel as if they lack both agency and meaning when it comes to their future roles in the world. They feel as if they are about to enter a rat race and often fail to see the meaning and relevance of what they are studying and learning. They themselves do not feel relevant.

But usefulness is only one dimension. Students may or may not experience their learning as connected to their own lives and futures. Many students can sense that what they are studying is supposed to matter yet still struggle to imagine how they themselves matter within the worlds they are preparing to enter. For educators, then, relevance involves more than asking whether a course is useful. It means that we ask whether our teaching helps students see themselves as people whose learning, questions, and futures matter.

This, then, is what I mean by an ethical and relevant educator: someone who teaches from truth, justice, and compassion and strives to do so with adab; someone who labors to cultivate conditions for relevant knowledge and helps students feel relevant themselves.

But I recognize that I don’t teach in a vacuum, and the other half of my question shifts from who I am trying to be to what I am trying to offer: not just any learning but meaningful and sustainable learning. I will take up that half in my next column: moving from the educator I am trying to become to the concrete practices that might make learning worth my students’ while.

These reflections have already begun to change small things for me, such as how I frame participation, how I explain the purpose of assignments, how I respond to the silence, and how I invite students to connect course questions to their lives. These are not solutions, but they are my attempts to move from reflection toward practice. As difficult as this past semester was, it taught me a great deal about myself and myself as an educator, and for my students and their silence I am grateful.

For now, I return to the silent classroom I started with. I know that naming these principles does not by itself fill that silence. It does, however, change what I am listening for. And the principles of truth, justice, compassion, and adab are not a method I can hand my students; they are a way of being I want to model so my students can recognize, appreciate, and begin to carry them on their own.


Mays Imad is an associate professor of physiology at Connecticut College. Previously, she taught for 14 years at Pima Community College, where she also founded the teaching and learning center. She is a Gardner Institute Fellow for Undergraduate Education, an Association of American Colleges & Universities Senior STEM Fellow, a Mind and Life Institute Fellow, a scholar-in-residence at Georgetown University’s Red House, and a research fellow with the Centre for the Study of the Afterlife of Violence and the Reparative Quest (AVReQ) at the University of Stellenbosch.

The post On Being an Ethical and Relevant Educator appeared first on The Teaching Professor.