You are currently viewing Human Intelligence Only: Engaging Deep Learning with Tech-Free Activities

Human Intelligence Only: Engaging Deep Learning with Tech-Free Activities

I can’t be the only instructor who has walked around the classroom during a carefully-designed active learning activity only to find students using their laptops to work on other homework, chat with friends, or, in one memorable case, watch a baseball game. Devices have long been ubiquitous in classrooms, often necessary for our tech-connected modes of learning while simultaneously one of the biggest distractions from learning.

With the advent of generative AI, the ever-present device poses a new problem. The issue is no longer only that a device can distract students from thinking but that it can also do the thinking students were supposed to practice. If I ask students to submit a minute paper at the end of class, the AI bots on their computers practically jump out of their codes to ask, Do you want me to do that for you?

In response to this issue, I started implementing a simple classroom practice I call human-intelligence-only activities: short periods during which students must put away their devices and use only their own thinking to engage with the problem at hand. Designating an activity as human intelligence only does not require me to invent any new active learning techniques. Freewriting with pen and paper, working through problems together on a whiteboard, annotating a printed text, or participating in peer discussion can all become human-intelligence-only activities. What matters is the designation. For this brief period, technological assistance is intentionally unavailable. In one simple designation, I can engage multiple pedagogical principles: making room for productive struggle, communicating confidence in students’ abilities, and modeling the scaffolding of AI use.

Promoting deep thinking through tech-free spaces

Karen Spira has recently argued that higher education should put resources toward creating “human intelligence laboratories”: physical spaces where students go to practice what they’ve learned without access to technology. Tech-free spaces, she writes, can “enable particular kinds of thinking,” particularly the kind of deep, engaged thinking where learning happens. With human-intelligence-only activities, instructors can create a smaller version of such a laboratory right inside an ordinary classroom.

Students need intervals in which they cannot immediately look something up, generate an idea, or ask a tool how to proceed. Those intervals give them the chance to sit with uncertainty, make an attempt to solve a complex problem, revise their thinking, and discover how far they can get on their own. Over time, that practice can strengthen both intellectual self-confidence and a sense of agency over the learning process. The goal is not to make learning artificially difficult, but to preserve some opportunities for students to experience the productive struggle through which learning often occurs.

Reframing device removal as pedagogy

Designating some activities as human intelligence only also changes the meaning of putting devices away. In many college classrooms, the clearest signal that students must put away their devices comes during high-stakes testing, when the purpose is to prevent cheating or verify what students can do independently. Students may then associate device removal with surveillance, control, or mistrust.

Low-stakes human-intelligence-only activities communicate something different. A short period of discussion, freewriting, or problem solving without technological assistance signals that sustained attention and unassisted thinking are themselves worth cultivating. It also communicates confidence in students’ intellectual abilities. We’re asking them to work without technology because we believe they are capable of engaging deeply on their own.

Over time, these experiences may help students see technology-free learning not simply as a restriction imposed by an instructor but as one mode of intellectual work they can choose deliberately.

Teaching students when to use AI

Perhaps most importantly, human-intelligence-only activities teach an aspect of AI literacy that receives too little attention: not simply whether to use AI but when in the intellectual process to use it.

Generative AI is forcing instructors to navigate what Kevin Yee, Laurie Uttich, Elizabeth Giltner, and Anastasia Bojanowski call the “AI educational double-bind”: We need to prepare students to use AI ethically and effectively while also helping them avoid becoming overly dependent on it. One way through that tension is to think about AI use as a matter of sequencing.

Students may benefit from engaging independently with a problem before technological assistance becomes available. When students have already wrestled with a question, developed an interpretation, or attempted a solution, they have a basis for deciding whether an AI response is useful, incomplete, or simply wrong. Without that prior engagement, students risk allowing AI to define both the problem and its possible answers for them. Delaying AI, then, is not a rejection of the technology but preparation for using it well.

Putting human-intelligence-only activities into practice

Human-intelligence-only activities take a page from low-tech pedagogy without requiring instructors to adopt a fully low-tech classroom. That makes it particularly useful in courses where students have good reasons to use laptops, phones, or AI tools during other parts of class. A few principles can make the practice work better:

  • Establish the concept early. Explain what the designation means and why you are using it. Students are more likely to understand a device-free activity when they know that the restriction serves a particular learning purpose.
  • Make the boundaries clear. Tell students when devices need to be put away and when they can come back out. A defined interval makes clear that human intelligence only is not a blanket technology ban but a particular mode of learning.
  • Use it selectively. If everything in the course is human intelligence only, you have simply created a no-device policy. That may make sense in some classrooms, but the value of the designation lies partly in the contrast. Students experience both technologically assisted and unassisted thinking and begin to recognize that each has its place.

Current conversations about AI literacy understandably emphasize assessment redesign, ethical use, and preparing students for an AI-enabled workplace. But appropriate AI use must also include knowing when technological assistance is best delayed. Human intelligence only is a small intervention, but one that gives students repeated opportunities to experience their own capacities before turning to AI. In an educational environment increasingly shaped by artificial intelligence, we can help our students become AI literate partly by teaching them to recognize when human intelligence is enough.


Tanya Bomsta is a writing instructor and a staff member at the Ohio State University.

The post Human Intelligence Only: Engaging Deep Learning with Tech-Free Activities appeared first on The Teaching Professor.