You are currently viewing Beyond the Syllabus: Teaching Students “How to Get an A” in Their Course

Beyond the Syllabus: Teaching Students “How to Get an A” in Their Course

When instructors sit down to write their syllabi before the semester, one challenge they face is how to communicate to students the skills and habits they need to succeed. Syllabi primarily outline course policies, learning objectives, and assignments, which means they typically focus less on teaching students how they should prepare for class, engage with course materials, and participate effectively. As a result, many of the course expectations essential to student success remain implicit, putting students at a disadvantage before the course even begins.

In “The Purpose of a Syllabus,” Jay Parkes and Mary B. Harris, drawing on Judith Grunert’s work on “learning-centered” syllabi, argue that the syllabus has three primary functions: to be a contract between instructor and student, to serve as a permanent record, and to serve as an aid to student learning (Parkes & Harris, 2002). In my experience, most syllabi do the first two well and the third less so. When I ask faculty whether their syllabi explicitly outline the skills and habits students need to succeed, many say no, because they believe that including this kind of guidance runs against the tone of the syllabus, which is to focus more on the “what” of the course and less on the “how.”

To bridge this gap in student success, I pair the syllabus with a supplementary document called “How Do I Get an A in This Class?” Though it might suggest a transactional approach to education, the name is meant to meet students where they are. The document’s goal is to make implicit expectations explicit, which is beneficial for all students, especially first-generation ones not yet accustomed to the norms of higher education (Gable, 2022). More broadly, the document aligns students’ intentions with the course learning outcomes, emphasizing how getting an A requires not only memorizing content but also developing discipline-specific skills and habits, both in the classroom and beyond it.

Writing this document has been impactful without being onerous. Most iterations are two to four pages long. To avoid overwhelming students, I focus primarily on those skills that are most pertinent to the course. I typically start by asking myself two questions: What does an ideal class look like? and What assignments will students complete in the course? These questions help me identify which skills students will need. For example, in my philosophy courses, I want class time to be largely discussion based, leaving room for students to ask questions, evaluate arguments, and raise objections, skills they will also practice in their written assignments. For students to be successful in this environment, they need to know how to read closely (e.g., annotate texts, take effective notes, and identify arguments) and how to engage in thoughtful dialogue with their classmates. Consequently, much of the document focuses on distinguishing A-level reading and engagement from B and C levels. I find that using letter grades in this context replaces the assumption that studying is an all-or-nothing proposition with the idea that learning consists of practices that improve with intention and effort. In this way, the document translates learning objectives into actionable guidance for students.

Although my examples come from philosophy, these design choices translate across disciplines. For example, biology instructors might emphasize lab notebooks and data preparation, while history instructors might focus on primary source analysis and argumentation. The guiding questions above can help instructors clarify the skills and habits they want students to develop.

Compared to the syllabus, my supplementary document is more casual in tone, since it is less a rubric and more of an advice column aimed at helping students succeed. My version typically includes elements of a professional autobiography. When I write about how students should prepare for class, I discuss how those same strategies have worked for me consistently, occasionally interjecting anecdotes from my academic career. In this way, students gain a clearer understanding of my pedagogy and the experiences that informed it.

One advantage of writing this supplement is that it signals approachability without undermining the rigor of the course. In their article “Effect of Syllabus Tone: Students’ Perceptions of Instructor and Course,” Richard Harnish and Robert Bridges (2011) found that students who read a syllabus written in a friendly tone are more likely to rate their instructor as approachable and motivated to teach the course. But they are also more likely to believe that the course will be easier. I find that having students read my supplement resists this tradeoff insofar as it helps them to see their instructor as a practitioner whose content expertise is supported by years of training, experimentation, and failure. The goal is for students to feel like apprentices learning a craft in which their appreciation for the subject matter is grounded in their understanding of the processes required to create it. Furthermore, the document signals to students that expertise is more than the recounting of information; it includes the process by which that information is gathered, interpreted, and communicated, a process honed through experience. I find it more important than ever that students understand this distinction as AI becomes increasingly capable of demonstrating outward competence without the requisite experience supporting it. In this way, the document cautions students against overreliance on AI but in a manner that feels justified and earned and not like a blanket warning against cheating.

Since adopting this supplement, I have received positive feedback in formal course evaluations, including higher scores for class organization, clarity of grading criteria, and high expectations. Students also report that courses remain challenging, even as expectations feel clearer. Additionally, I have noticed improvements in students’ engagement and written work. These experiences remind me not to assume that underperformance is the result of laziness or that low engagement is the result of disinterest but to consider first whether students understand what is expected of them. They suggest that a rigorous learning environment depends on not only setting high standards but also explicitly telling students how to succeed in the course—in effect, how to get an A.

References

Gable, R. (2022). The hidden curriculum: First generation students at legacy universities. Princeton University Press.

Harnish, R. J., & Bridges, K. R. (2011). Effect of syllabus tone: Students’ perceptions of instructor and course. Social Psychology of Education, 14(3), 319–330. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11218-011-9152-4

Parkes, J., & Harris, M. B. (2002). The purposes of a syllabus. College Teaching, 50(2), 55–61. https://doi.org/10.1080/87567550209595875


Andrew Jussaume is a philosopher and educator with 15 years of teaching experience. He holds a PhD in philosophy from Duquesne University and teaches at Boston College High School. He has taught at the College of the Holy Cross, Boston College, and Providence College and facilitated faculty development workshops on teaching and learning.

The post Beyond the Syllabus: Teaching Students “How to Get an A” in Their Course appeared first on The Teaching Professor.